If I could write a one-sentence review of the book I've just finished reading, it would say, "This book is just too bad to review." Instead I'm supposed to produce 800 words of polished prose presenting a balanced evaluation of a book that does not merit 800 words or the time and effort I will have to put into writing 800 words or the time I've already spent reading the book. I'd be happier if the book were bad enough to be amusing, if it were studded with bizarrely inept prose and hilariously mixed metaphors. But no: it's written competently enough to resist jeering. It's not even bad enough to be interesting; it's just bad.
The characters are sketchy; we're told more or less what the main character looks like, but everyone else is just a name on a page. The children talk like adults and the adults act like children, none of them the least bit believably; they converse in stilted speeches, never interrupt, never stumble or stutter. The pages are studded with names of places and streets and buildings, but the places exist merely as points on a map, without weather or color or light or air. The metaphors are overworked; one poor unfortunate dead kitten earns enough Frequent Metaphor Miles to travel first-class through the collected works of Dickens and half of Thackeray.
And what can I say about the plot? There's a mystery at the center of it, a mystery that is supposed to serve as a metaphor for What's Wrong With America Today and provide closure and healing to the open wounds of our post-911 world. Except it doesn't. I figured out the deep dark secret within the first two chapters, but I kept thinking I must be wrong. "It can't be this obvious," I thought. "Surely these clues are just typical red herrings cleverly placed to distract me from the real story." But no: any reasonably sentient reader could figure out the purported mystery so quickly that there would be no reason to keep reading beyond page 20 except to confirm what is already so abundantly clear: that the only healing the book will provide is a nice colorful band-aid and a hearty "Cheer up!"
The only thing in the whole book that made me want to cheer up was finally closing it, but now I have to open it up again and write a review. The whole situation makes me want to kick something. I think I'll drop-kick that dead kitten clear back to Beowulf.
Sunday, April 08, 2007
Partly sunny with chance of salami
All week we've been enjoying some yummy treats left behind by our German houseguests, who showered us with chocolates, marzipan, salami, and tiny dense loaves of rye and pumpernickel. We've been nibbling on the sweets all week, so today we decided to work the savory items into our Easter dinner. I topped some rounds of pumpernickel bread with mustard, havarti cheese, and hard salami to make darling little canapes. We are not normally canape people, so it was a delicious treat.
Here's my issue, though: working with the salami left my hands slick with fat, and heating the canapes resulted in little pools of fat all over the plate. It was the best salami I've ever eaten, but I could feel my arteries clogging up with every bite. If we ate like this every day, we'd never fit out the front door. I suppose it's a good thing we don't get showered with salami every week.
Here's my issue, though: working with the salami left my hands slick with fat, and heating the canapes resulted in little pools of fat all over the plate. It was the best salami I've ever eaten, but I could feel my arteries clogging up with every bite. If we ate like this every day, we'd never fit out the front door. I suppose it's a good thing we don't get showered with salami every week.
Saturday, April 07, 2007
Call of the wild
Snow again this morning and the goldfinches are out in force. Twelve or 14 of them were flitting around the feeders this morning, about half of them bright yellow males. I guess it's a good year for goldfinches. I saw the first kingfisher of the season yesterday but we've been hearing them for a week or so. The towhees are back and very vocal, but I'm still waiting for the orioles. This year there wasn't much of a gap between the departure of the juncoes and the arrival of the towhees, assuring a sort of color balance in the yard: one group of little black birds leaves and another arrives to take its place. The towhees are singing "Drink your tea!" Who could resist such a charming command?
Friday, April 06, 2007
Avoiding crucifixion, for now
It ought to be illegal to schedule meetings on Friday afternoons in spring, and to schedule three meetings in a row is just inhumane. The lunch meeting was not bad, but then I went to a two-hour faculty council meeting where it's a good thing it was my turn to take minutes because otherwise I would have had to put my head down on the table and start snoring.
Last came the Planning Committee meeting, where a colleague and I represented the English department for our quadrennial program review. Yes, every four years each department has to go before a committee to present a lengthy report justifying its continued existence, and this time it was our turn. I've been obsessing over this meeting since I turned in the report in January; I've even spent some time responding to potential questions in my sleep, just as I used to do while preparing for my dissertation defense. I'm not sure what I was expecting, but on a scale from 1 (a hearty pat on the back) to 10 (crucifixion), I would say we came out at about a 2. But we won't really know until the commitee releases its official report. Meanwhile, I intend to avoid all meetings for a good long while--at least until Monday. Then it starts all over again.
Last came the Planning Committee meeting, where a colleague and I represented the English department for our quadrennial program review. Yes, every four years each department has to go before a committee to present a lengthy report justifying its continued existence, and this time it was our turn. I've been obsessing over this meeting since I turned in the report in January; I've even spent some time responding to potential questions in my sleep, just as I used to do while preparing for my dissertation defense. I'm not sure what I was expecting, but on a scale from 1 (a hearty pat on the back) to 10 (crucifixion), I would say we came out at about a 2. But we won't really know until the commitee releases its official report. Meanwhile, I intend to avoid all meetings for a good long while--at least until Monday. Then it starts all over again.
Thursday, April 05, 2007
Non-ominously speaking
I told my visitor that I've been making students angry all week, but she pooh-poohed the possibility: "You are the most benign person I know," she said. Somehow, I did not find this comforting.
Benign is the word we want to hear if we're talking about tumors, but even a benign tumor is still a tumor, and who wants to be a tumor?
I don't often see the word benign applied to people, and the examples in my dictionary are not helpful: "a benign smile" belongs on a clueless bumbler like Mr. Magoo, while "a benign king" doles out largess to his doting subjects, which I would be happy to do if I had any largess left to dole out--or any doting subjects, for that matter.
Benign describes weather that promotes health or omens that are favorable, so perhaps my visitor considers me the opposite of ominous. My dictionary wants me to apply benign to any kind, compassionate, or gracious person, but to my mind benign suggests a harmlessness that borders on the ineffectual, like a tumor that doesn't hurt but doesn't help either: it just sits there harmlessly taking up space.
But at least it's a happy tumor, grinning like an idiot in a non-ominous manner. Don't be alarmed, I'll tell my angry students. I'm totally benign.
Benign is the word we want to hear if we're talking about tumors, but even a benign tumor is still a tumor, and who wants to be a tumor?
I don't often see the word benign applied to people, and the examples in my dictionary are not helpful: "a benign smile" belongs on a clueless bumbler like Mr. Magoo, while "a benign king" doles out largess to his doting subjects, which I would be happy to do if I had any largess left to dole out--or any doting subjects, for that matter.
Benign describes weather that promotes health or omens that are favorable, so perhaps my visitor considers me the opposite of ominous. My dictionary wants me to apply benign to any kind, compassionate, or gracious person, but to my mind benign suggests a harmlessness that borders on the ineffectual, like a tumor that doesn't hurt but doesn't help either: it just sits there harmlessly taking up space.
But at least it's a happy tumor, grinning like an idiot in a non-ominous manner. Don't be alarmed, I'll tell my angry students. I'm totally benign.
Snow business
It's snowing this morning and it may be my fault: I took my winter coat to by dry-cleaned. Sorry. I should have known that taking my coat to the cleaner's was just asking for more cold weather. Next time I'll wait until July.
Wednesday, April 04, 2007
Where to park your apostrophe
A long time ago in a school district far, far away, a bunch of high school students flunked a particular section of the high school competency test--the test they needed to pass in order to receive a high school diploma rather than a Certificate of Attendance. In fact, so many students flunked this particular section of the test that the entire student body (more than 2000 students) endured periodic remediation sessions on the subject--in every class. At a certain time every week, every class would stop what it was doing and every teacher would present a short and simple lesson on the correct way to form possessives of plural nouns. A visitor to the building might have been surprised to see the same lesson being presented in French classes, driver's ed classes, art classes, and shop classes: "To form the possessive of a plural noun, first write down the plural form of the noun; if it ends in s, add an apostrophe, and if it does not end in s, and 's."
It seems so simple! And yet today I have on my desk a pile of papers dealing with the playwright Suzan-Lori Parks, and so far I have seen the following spellings: Parks, Park's, Parks', Parks's, Parkses, and Parkses'. Some of those are correct in certain contexts, but they are being used in these papers almost interchangeably. So I did a little remediation at the beginning of class today, drawing on the valuable lesson I learned in every high school class I ever took: to make a noun plural, add s or es (no apostrophe). To make it possessive, add 's. To make a plural noun possessive, see the paragraph above. So if we are studying a play by Suzan-Lori Parks, it is Parks's play, but she might be related to a bunch of other Parkses who all live in the Parkses' house. See? Easy as pie.
So I guess I should be grateful to my driver's education teacher: I may have flunked parallel parking, but at least I know where to park an apostrophe.
It seems so simple! And yet today I have on my desk a pile of papers dealing with the playwright Suzan-Lori Parks, and so far I have seen the following spellings: Parks, Park's, Parks', Parks's, Parkses, and Parkses'. Some of those are correct in certain contexts, but they are being used in these papers almost interchangeably. So I did a little remediation at the beginning of class today, drawing on the valuable lesson I learned in every high school class I ever took: to make a noun plural, add s or es (no apostrophe). To make it possessive, add 's. To make a plural noun possessive, see the paragraph above. So if we are studying a play by Suzan-Lori Parks, it is Parks's play, but she might be related to a bunch of other Parkses who all live in the Parkses' house. See? Easy as pie.
So I guess I should be grateful to my driver's education teacher: I may have flunked parallel parking, but at least I know where to park an apostrophe.
Tuesday, April 03, 2007
Wild America
Over the weekend we were out for a drive with the visiting Germans when suddenly a roly-poly critter scurried across the road. The German dad slammed on the brakes and said, "What's that?"
"That's a groundhog," I said. There followed a rapid flurry of German as the dad described this wondrous creature to his enthralled family members. I didn't understand a word of it, but he spoke with the kind of excitement I might use to describe a close encounter with a unicorn. Finally he turned to me and said, "What do they do?"
I had to think about this for a moment. "They get into the garden and eat up your vegetables," I said. "People shoot them."
"For meat?"
"No," I said, "for vengeance."
I was rescued from further explanation by the sudden appearance in the road of another roly-poly critter that excited similar excitement: a VW bug. That I can explain. Groundhogs, on the other hand, defy explanation.
I thought about suggesting that our visitors take some groundhogs back to Germany with them, but they'd never make it through security.
"That's a groundhog," I said. There followed a rapid flurry of German as the dad described this wondrous creature to his enthralled family members. I didn't understand a word of it, but he spoke with the kind of excitement I might use to describe a close encounter with a unicorn. Finally he turned to me and said, "What do they do?"
I had to think about this for a moment. "They get into the garden and eat up your vegetables," I said. "People shoot them."
"For meat?"
"No," I said, "for vengeance."
I was rescued from further explanation by the sudden appearance in the road of another roly-poly critter that excited similar excitement: a VW bug. That I can explain. Groundhogs, on the other hand, defy explanation.
I thought about suggesting that our visitors take some groundhogs back to Germany with them, but they'd never make it through security.
Monday, April 02, 2007
Only you can stop prevention! (Slowly)
The prevention of this change is slowly becoming harder to stop.
I had to look at that sentence several times to figure out what's wrong with it: is it difficult to prevent change or to stop the prevention of change (slowly)?
Don't know. Don't care. Don't want to think about it.
Is it too early to go home?
That's my story and I'm sticking with it
May I please be excused from writing today? We had these weekend houseguests, see, our former exchange student and his family from Germany, five people with various levels of English language skills, so I spent a good part of last week preparing the house--cooking and cleaning and shifting some furniture--which went pretty well until I decided to get caught up on the ironing and twisted my back (Is that a sign from God or what?), and if it's difficult to tell people "I wrenched my back ironing" it is doubly difficult to sleep with an intensely throbbing back so I ended up catching a few Z's on the floor between vigorous bouts of cooking food for the 30 teens who came over Saturday for a cookout followed by the 15 older folks who came over for lunch after church Sunday in the pouring rain and so had to be accommodated inside the house, and although it is acceptable to ask 17-year-olds to sit on the floor, I hesitate to do the same with an 88-year-old woman who walks with a cane, so we had to set up a table in the living room and surround it with a mismatched assemblage of chairs including an antique piano stool, two rolling desk chairs in clashing colors, and a blue recliner, which worked fairly well until it was time for everyone to get up and go and then we realized there was no way out.
But we survived all that. The Germans left this morning just as I was leaving for work, so my leave-taking was punctuated by a hearty round of handshakes and hugs and a great deal of fumbling about with various pieces of luggage and cameras and maps and sunglasses, so I was halfway to campus before I realized that I didn't have my briefcase or anything in it, including the pile of freshman papers I need to finish grading today as well as everything I needed for this morning's 11:00 a.m. American Lit class. The right thing to do would have been to turn around and go back for the briefcase, but turning around always feels like defeat to me so I kept going and then spent the entire morning coming up with Plan B, which involved finding a copy of the film version of David Mamet's Glengarry Glen Ross, which was available only at a video store that is going out of business and is therefore renting nothing and selling everything, so the only way I could show clips from the film in this morning's class was to drive out there and buy the DVD, which is fine because I'll surely use it again in the future because my students love the play, love love love it, much more than they love The America Play, which we will discuss on Wednesday, by which time I ought to have recovered from the thrilling events of the past week.
That's my excuse for not writing today. Thanks for understanding.
But we survived all that. The Germans left this morning just as I was leaving for work, so my leave-taking was punctuated by a hearty round of handshakes and hugs and a great deal of fumbling about with various pieces of luggage and cameras and maps and sunglasses, so I was halfway to campus before I realized that I didn't have my briefcase or anything in it, including the pile of freshman papers I need to finish grading today as well as everything I needed for this morning's 11:00 a.m. American Lit class. The right thing to do would have been to turn around and go back for the briefcase, but turning around always feels like defeat to me so I kept going and then spent the entire morning coming up with Plan B, which involved finding a copy of the film version of David Mamet's Glengarry Glen Ross, which was available only at a video store that is going out of business and is therefore renting nothing and selling everything, so the only way I could show clips from the film in this morning's class was to drive out there and buy the DVD, which is fine because I'll surely use it again in the future because my students love the play, love love love it, much more than they love The America Play, which we will discuss on Wednesday, by which time I ought to have recovered from the thrilling events of the past week.
That's my excuse for not writing today. Thanks for understanding.
Thursday, March 29, 2007
Matt the mnemonic
At 8 a.m. on a beautiful spring day, it's difficult to get students excited about whether to underline a title or put it in quotation marks, so I ask for a volunteer, and eventually a student--let's call him Matt--comes to the front of the room.
"Look at Matt," I tell the class. "If he were a publication, he could be a newspaper or a magazine or an anthology or any number of other things, but let's call him a book."
Matt just stands there.
"Since he is a whole publication complete in itself, let's underline him."
I mime drawing a line on the floor under Matt's feet, and then I write Matt on the board and underline it.
"Now let's talk about Matt's arm. Matt, put your arm straight out to your side." Being a good sport, Matt complies. "If we cut off Matt's arm and toss it out in the hall, it won't get anywhere on its own. It is not independent but rather functions as a part of a larger whole. If Matt is a newspaper, his arm is an article; if Matt is a book, his arm is a chapter; if Matt is a poetry anthology, his arm is a single poem."
Matt's arm does not look particularly poetic, but we go on anyway.
"Since Matt's arm is a small part of a larger whole, let's put it in quotation marks."
Matt holds his arm up close to the whiteboard and I surround it with quotation marks.
"If you are trying to decide whether to put a title of a work in quotation marks or underline it," I say, "Let Matt be your guide: if the work is more like Matt, underline it; if it's more like Matt's arm, put it in quotation marks."
Matt seems delighted to be allowed to sit down. I don't know about Matt's arm.
We spend the next few minutes looking at titles of different types of sources: articles, books, poems, articles about books, books about poems, articles about articles. I ask the students how to format the titles, and they get most of them right. When I ask why, they say, "Because it's Matt" or "because it's Matt's arm."
Maybe they'll remember this little lesson and apply it in their writing assignments, or maybe not. I leave the students with one final suggestion: "If you're frantically trying to finish a paper at 4 a.m. and you can't remember whether to underline a title or put it in quotation marks, don't call me," I tell them. "Call Matt. I'm sure he'll be happy to help."
"Look at Matt," I tell the class. "If he were a publication, he could be a newspaper or a magazine or an anthology or any number of other things, but let's call him a book."
Matt just stands there.
"Since he is a whole publication complete in itself, let's underline him."
I mime drawing a line on the floor under Matt's feet, and then I write Matt on the board and underline it.
"Now let's talk about Matt's arm. Matt, put your arm straight out to your side." Being a good sport, Matt complies. "If we cut off Matt's arm and toss it out in the hall, it won't get anywhere on its own. It is not independent but rather functions as a part of a larger whole. If Matt is a newspaper, his arm is an article; if Matt is a book, his arm is a chapter; if Matt is a poetry anthology, his arm is a single poem."
Matt's arm does not look particularly poetic, but we go on anyway.
"Since Matt's arm is a small part of a larger whole, let's put it in quotation marks."
Matt holds his arm up close to the whiteboard and I surround it with quotation marks.
"If you are trying to decide whether to put a title of a work in quotation marks or underline it," I say, "Let Matt be your guide: if the work is more like Matt, underline it; if it's more like Matt's arm, put it in quotation marks."
Matt seems delighted to be allowed to sit down. I don't know about Matt's arm.
We spend the next few minutes looking at titles of different types of sources: articles, books, poems, articles about books, books about poems, articles about articles. I ask the students how to format the titles, and they get most of them right. When I ask why, they say, "Because it's Matt" or "because it's Matt's arm."
Maybe they'll remember this little lesson and apply it in their writing assignments, or maybe not. I leave the students with one final suggestion: "If you're frantically trying to finish a paper at 4 a.m. and you can't remember whether to underline a title or put it in quotation marks, don't call me," I tell them. "Call Matt. I'm sure he'll be happy to help."
Wednesday, March 28, 2007
Bookish
A student came into my office seeking help on an assignment, but at first he had to satisfy his curiosity: "Are all these books yours," he asked, "or does the library let you borrow them?"
If he finds my office overwhelming, I'd hate to let him see my house.
If he finds my office overwhelming, I'd hate to let him see my house.
Tuesday, March 27, 2007
Thanks but no thanks, sweetie
Today a student stopped by my office to get my signature on a form and as she was leaving, she said, "Thanks, sweetie!"
Let me point out that I had never seen this student before and I spent no more than 60 seconds with her today. I didn't do anything particularly sweet--just signed on the dotted line. But still she called me "sweetie."
Suddenly time slipped a few decades and I thought I was back in Florida waiting tables and trying to maintain some semblance of dignity while total strangers called me sweetie, honey, sugar, and darlin'. Just because some thirsty guy comes in with a dollar for a cup of coffee I'm supposed to be his sweetie? Please.
Now I sit in the big corner office with the words "Department Chair" on the door and the only person who calls me "Sweetie" is my spouse. I don't miss being everyone's sweetie and I'd rather not fill that role again anytime soon; in particular, I'm not interested in being "Sweetie" to my students. But at the time she said it, I found myself as speechless as an actor who stumbles onto the wrong stage: I'm all prepared to deliver Hamlet's soliloquy, but all of a sudden I'm in the spotlight but the show is Grease.
So I just sat there with my mouth open while she walked away. Next time I might have the presence of mind to say "You're welcome," but do I dare call a student "Darlin'"?
Let me point out that I had never seen this student before and I spent no more than 60 seconds with her today. I didn't do anything particularly sweet--just signed on the dotted line. But still she called me "sweetie."
Suddenly time slipped a few decades and I thought I was back in Florida waiting tables and trying to maintain some semblance of dignity while total strangers called me sweetie, honey, sugar, and darlin'. Just because some thirsty guy comes in with a dollar for a cup of coffee I'm supposed to be his sweetie? Please.
Now I sit in the big corner office with the words "Department Chair" on the door and the only person who calls me "Sweetie" is my spouse. I don't miss being everyone's sweetie and I'd rather not fill that role again anytime soon; in particular, I'm not interested in being "Sweetie" to my students. But at the time she said it, I found myself as speechless as an actor who stumbles onto the wrong stage: I'm all prepared to deliver Hamlet's soliloquy, but all of a sudden I'm in the spotlight but the show is Grease.
So I just sat there with my mouth open while she walked away. Next time I might have the presence of mind to say "You're welcome," but do I dare call a student "Darlin'"?
Monday, March 26, 2007
Rara avis
If you'd visited my back yard yesterday, you might have caught a glimpse of the rare Black-Footed, Red-Faced Wobble-Bucket flittering about the deck. In the beginning, the deck and environs sported green and black blotches of algae and other gunk that thrives in a moist climate, but the three of us went out there armed with buckets and rags and Pine-Sol and algicide and by the time we were done, the deck and lawn furniture and siding were sparkly clean but the blotches had migrated toward me. My feet were black, my face was red, and my skin felt sticky all over from all the times I sloshed that bucket full of slimy Pine-Sol all over my clothes. So I sat back in a clean deck chair and watched the birds, particularly a couple of phoebes chasing each other around the edge of the woods. Or maybe the phoebes were watching me. If so, I hope they were delighted at the opportunity to place a check-mark on their life lists next to the Black-Footed, Red-Faced Wobble Bucket. That's not something you see every day.
Saturday, March 24, 2007
A walk on the wild side
I took advantage of a break in the rain to walk around the property and see what's up. The answers are many and varied.
Fog shrouded the lower meadow and buzzards were circling above. A large raptor was calling from the top of the tallest sycamore, but it flew off before I could identify it. Probably a hawk. Bald eagles have made a remarkable comeback all over the river valley and I keep hoping to see some here, but so far no luck. I also failed to find any indigo buntings; I've seen them only once this season and I don't know whether they're nesting here or not. It's still early. They could pop up at any time.
Daffodils are up and blooming. No trilliums yet, but conditions are ripe so we'll surely see some soon. I don't know why I get so excited about seeing the first trillium--it's not as if someone is planning to give me a prize. Nevertheless I look forward to their return with undue excitement.
After two days of steady rain, the creek is way, way up and really loud. It's amazing the racket that tiny little creek can make--sounds like Niagara out there. The mud level on the hill is high, and the abundant deer tracks suggest that the deer are up and about but not hanging around in plain sight.
Finally, I'm up. This is the first time I've walked up the hill in at least a month, and I've missed it. It makes me feel good to get up early and go for a hike, and it should keep my spirits up all day long.
Fog shrouded the lower meadow and buzzards were circling above. A large raptor was calling from the top of the tallest sycamore, but it flew off before I could identify it. Probably a hawk. Bald eagles have made a remarkable comeback all over the river valley and I keep hoping to see some here, but so far no luck. I also failed to find any indigo buntings; I've seen them only once this season and I don't know whether they're nesting here or not. It's still early. They could pop up at any time.
Daffodils are up and blooming. No trilliums yet, but conditions are ripe so we'll surely see some soon. I don't know why I get so excited about seeing the first trillium--it's not as if someone is planning to give me a prize. Nevertheless I look forward to their return with undue excitement.
After two days of steady rain, the creek is way, way up and really loud. It's amazing the racket that tiny little creek can make--sounds like Niagara out there. The mud level on the hill is high, and the abundant deer tracks suggest that the deer are up and about but not hanging around in plain sight.
Finally, I'm up. This is the first time I've walked up the hill in at least a month, and I've missed it. It makes me feel good to get up early and go for a hike, and it should keep my spirits up all day long.
Friday, March 23, 2007
Racist stereotype or progressive protest?
My favorite poster had been hanging in my office for a week or so when one of my students looked closely at it and said, "That's offensive." She may be right, but I'm not sure what to do about it.
Here's the story: the poster, created by the Ohio Preservation Council (view it here), encourages viewers to "Preserve Ohio's Book Heritage"; it features full-color photos of first editions of books by such early Ohio authors as Charles Chesnutt, Paul Laurence Dunbar, William Dean Howells, Lafcadio Hearn, and even Harriett Beecher Stowe (not a native Ohioan, but she did a lot of writing here). Many of the covers are richly decorated: William Dean Howells's Tuscan Cities (1886) is festooned with architectural elements, while Paul Laurence Dunbar's Candle-Lightin' Time (1901) features a moon shining over a mass of lovely white flowers.
The cover that provoked my student's comment comes from Charles Chesnutt's first collection of short stories, The Conjure Woman (1899). The brown cover is mostly bare with a trio of figures at the top: two long-eared white rabbits and a grinning African-American man. (View a close-up of the cover here.) Displayed out of context, this image would certainly suggest a grinning Sambo figure, an unfortunate racist stereotype that I would not want hanging on my wall.
But a closer look reveals that the two rabbits are winking knowingly, as if aware that there's more to the story. And there is: the man on the cover represents not Joel Chandler Harris's appeasing Uncle Remus but Chesnutt's more subtle character, Uncle Julius, who is not nearly as simple as he seems. An ex-slave, Uncle Julius has no real resources except his tongue, which he employs to tell tall tales that seem frivolous at first but nevertheless manage to passionately portray the evils of racial discrimination while challenging white readers' assumptions about race.
The problem is that not everyone looking at the poster is aware of Chesnutt's groundbreaking work. If I leave the poster up, I risk offending people--but I also have the opportunity to spread the word about Charles Chesnutt. If I take it down, I lose my favorite poster.
The obvious solution is to require everyone who comes in my office to read The Conjure Woman, but that's unlikely to happen. So for now, the poster stays up until someone gives me a compelling reason to remove it.
Here's the story: the poster, created by the Ohio Preservation Council (view it here), encourages viewers to "Preserve Ohio's Book Heritage"; it features full-color photos of first editions of books by such early Ohio authors as Charles Chesnutt, Paul Laurence Dunbar, William Dean Howells, Lafcadio Hearn, and even Harriett Beecher Stowe (not a native Ohioan, but she did a lot of writing here). Many of the covers are richly decorated: William Dean Howells's Tuscan Cities (1886) is festooned with architectural elements, while Paul Laurence Dunbar's Candle-Lightin' Time (1901) features a moon shining over a mass of lovely white flowers.
The cover that provoked my student's comment comes from Charles Chesnutt's first collection of short stories, The Conjure Woman (1899). The brown cover is mostly bare with a trio of figures at the top: two long-eared white rabbits and a grinning African-American man. (View a close-up of the cover here.) Displayed out of context, this image would certainly suggest a grinning Sambo figure, an unfortunate racist stereotype that I would not want hanging on my wall.
But a closer look reveals that the two rabbits are winking knowingly, as if aware that there's more to the story. And there is: the man on the cover represents not Joel Chandler Harris's appeasing Uncle Remus but Chesnutt's more subtle character, Uncle Julius, who is not nearly as simple as he seems. An ex-slave, Uncle Julius has no real resources except his tongue, which he employs to tell tall tales that seem frivolous at first but nevertheless manage to passionately portray the evils of racial discrimination while challenging white readers' assumptions about race.
The problem is that not everyone looking at the poster is aware of Chesnutt's groundbreaking work. If I leave the poster up, I risk offending people--but I also have the opportunity to spread the word about Charles Chesnutt. If I take it down, I lose my favorite poster.
The obvious solution is to require everyone who comes in my office to read The Conjure Woman, but that's unlikely to happen. So for now, the poster stays up until someone gives me a compelling reason to remove it.
Thursday, March 22, 2007
Musical minivan
It's not every day that choirs of angels accompany me on my commute, but I certainly enjoy it when it happens. My daughter's college choir performed locally as part of their spring break concert tour, and we hosted some of the choir members at our house last night. This morning I squeezed six girls and their luggage into my minivan and drove them back to town, a 20-minute trip enlivened by their singing. Even at 7:30 a.m., they sang like angels. Wish I could carry them with me everywhere I go.
Last night's concert was also wonderful, and afterward a little old lady I've never seen before came up and thanked me. Me? What'd I do? "Thanks for sharing your daughter with us." That's about the sweetest thing anyone's ever said to me.
Now I have something to say to those other moms whose daughters sang me to school this morning: Thanks for sharing your daughter with me. They can sing in my car anytime.
Last night's concert was also wonderful, and afterward a little old lady I've never seen before came up and thanked me. Me? What'd I do? "Thanks for sharing your daughter with us." That's about the sweetest thing anyone's ever said to me.
Now I have something to say to those other moms whose daughters sang me to school this morning: Thanks for sharing your daughter with me. They can sing in my car anytime.
Wednesday, March 21, 2007
I'm getting too old for this
A student paper today informs me that "Technology has come a long way since the twentieth century." For instance, "In the twentieth century the radio and paper were the main ways to find out about the news going on in the world and also were used to catch your favorite team's ballgame. People kept in touch by using letters and also a phone call here and there. The twentieth century time period was very different to live in than in our society."
Ah yes, how I remember those thrilling days of yesteryear! Why, when I was in college, we pricked our fingers with sharp sticks and used the blood for ink! We wrote on rocks, of course, and when we ran out of rocks, we used fragments of satellites that had fallen out of the sky! We didn't know what they were, but we were grateful to those invisible sky deities for dropping these big chunks of writing material down on our heads!
Then, in the year 2001, everything changed. Suddenly, cellphones and computers were everywhere! Some of us have had a little trouble adjusting to these rapid changes; you still see a few slow ones occasionally pricking their fingers to write with blood on their flat-screen monitors. What Neanderthals. As usual, the young people are leading the way into the new millennium. In fact, I don't know how any of us ever managed to survive those primitive conditions. Thank heaven for the younger generation! They sure know what's what.
Ah yes, how I remember those thrilling days of yesteryear! Why, when I was in college, we pricked our fingers with sharp sticks and used the blood for ink! We wrote on rocks, of course, and when we ran out of rocks, we used fragments of satellites that had fallen out of the sky! We didn't know what they were, but we were grateful to those invisible sky deities for dropping these big chunks of writing material down on our heads!
Then, in the year 2001, everything changed. Suddenly, cellphones and computers were everywhere! Some of us have had a little trouble adjusting to these rapid changes; you still see a few slow ones occasionally pricking their fingers to write with blood on their flat-screen monitors. What Neanderthals. As usual, the young people are leading the way into the new millennium. In fact, I don't know how any of us ever managed to survive those primitive conditions. Thank heaven for the younger generation! They sure know what's what.
Tuesday, March 20, 2007
A challenge for Dewey
Today's Columbus Dispatch features an article by Mike Harden (read it here) about unusual items librarians find in returned books (money, condoms, strips of bacon) and in book drops (cats, flowers, mud). I was most surprised, though, by this statement: "Dirty diapers are commonly dumped in book drops."
Who dumps dirty diapers in book drops? And what do they expect librarians to do with them? File them in the stacks at 628 (Sanitary and Municipal Engineering)? Is this an etiquette problem (395, Etiquette and Manners), an ethical problem (177, Ethics of Social Relations), or a mental deficiency (153, Mental Processes and Intelligence)? Or does a problem like this simply defy the powers of the Dewey Decimal System? Would the Library of Congress classification system work any better?
For the benefit of anyone who might be confused about this issue, here are some simple guidelines:
1. Dump the diapers in the trash.
2. Dump the books in the book drop.
3. Take the kid to the library.
See how easy? If this three-step plan does not end the scourge of book-drop diaper-dumping, then file the human race under 574.5: Endangered Species.
Who dumps dirty diapers in book drops? And what do they expect librarians to do with them? File them in the stacks at 628 (Sanitary and Municipal Engineering)? Is this an etiquette problem (395, Etiquette and Manners), an ethical problem (177, Ethics of Social Relations), or a mental deficiency (153, Mental Processes and Intelligence)? Or does a problem like this simply defy the powers of the Dewey Decimal System? Would the Library of Congress classification system work any better?
For the benefit of anyone who might be confused about this issue, here are some simple guidelines:
1. Dump the diapers in the trash.
2. Dump the books in the book drop.
3. Take the kid to the library.
See how easy? If this three-step plan does not end the scourge of book-drop diaper-dumping, then file the human race under 574.5: Endangered Species.
Taking the garage out for a spin
Momentous occasion: last night we took the garage out for a test-drive. Yes: after three years of on-again, off-again construction, after losing a contractor who absconded with a pile of money without finishing the job and then watching helplessly as the unfinished structure was colonized by woodland creatures, after borrowing another wad of money to hire another contractor to finish the job, we now have a garage and guest room that are fully functional and ready for use.
It's not easy to get used to having a garage. For three years I've been zipping past the spot and parking farther up the hill and it's hard to get out of that habit, but for the past week or so I've remembered to park in the garage about half the time. It's everything I've ever wanted in a garage plus a lot more, and it got done in the nick of time because we have houseguests coming Wednesday night and we need that guest room to be up and running.
So last night we decided to take it for a trial spin, kicking all the tires first to make sure they were up to snuff. We sat in all the chairs, slept in the bed, showered in the bathroom, and tested all the light fixtures. After we turned off the lights, we noticed a bright green glow emanating from the kitchenette. Space aliens? No, the coffee maker has an illuminated dial so bright that if I held it aloft while rotating you'd swear I was a lighthouse. We had to turn the coffee-maker toward the wall and cover it up before we could sleep.
But sleep we did, and this morning we felt as if we'd finally awakened from a three-year nightmare. This garage is a real cream-puff. You ought to take it out for a spin!
It's not easy to get used to having a garage. For three years I've been zipping past the spot and parking farther up the hill and it's hard to get out of that habit, but for the past week or so I've remembered to park in the garage about half the time. It's everything I've ever wanted in a garage plus a lot more, and it got done in the nick of time because we have houseguests coming Wednesday night and we need that guest room to be up and running.
So last night we decided to take it for a trial spin, kicking all the tires first to make sure they were up to snuff. We sat in all the chairs, slept in the bed, showered in the bathroom, and tested all the light fixtures. After we turned off the lights, we noticed a bright green glow emanating from the kitchenette. Space aliens? No, the coffee maker has an illuminated dial so bright that if I held it aloft while rotating you'd swear I was a lighthouse. We had to turn the coffee-maker toward the wall and cover it up before we could sleep.
But sleep we did, and this morning we felt as if we'd finally awakened from a three-year nightmare. This garage is a real cream-puff. You ought to take it out for a spin!
Monday, March 19, 2007
Talking turkey
This morning I was zipping along the state highway at 55 miles per hour when I noticed a flock of wild turkeys in a field next to the road, at least 30 of them, three displaying their plumage. We often see wild turkeys in our neck of the woods, although not that many and never right out in the open next to the highway. I hit the brakes so I could get a better look, and that's what I was doing when a car came looming at breakneck pace into my rear-view mirror. So I didn't stay to watch the show. I did, however, avoid becoming the show, which is good because it would just be too ludicrous to get flattened on the highway while watching wild turkeys. "Turkey-Gawker Causes Rush-Hour Wreck" is not the headline I want to see on my obituary.
Saturday, March 17, 2007
Travels in Quinnehtukqut
As the sun rose the morning of the day when the walls and floors
The blacktop has buckled. The car jolts. Roots from these tall trees
and roof of her house were to be sawed into pieces, broken apart
have stretched beneath the road; water has seeped through the bed of
by crowbars, raised on jacks, liften onto flatbed trucks and driven
gravel and sand, and frozen during the winters; spring thaws have
six and a half miles southwest....
weakened the road's edges....
So begins the last section of Joshua Harmon's Quinnehtukqut, a book I've been alternately breezing and struggling through for two weeks now. This last section consists of two separate stories, one in normal type and one in italic, presented in alternating lines for more than 30 pages. It took me a while to figure out how to read these pages; I finally settled on reading the plain type all the way through and then starting over on the italics. I suppose it would be possible to simply read straight down the page as if these were lines of poetry, but this reading method obscures the narrative. Of course, that may be the point.
I can see several reasons Harmon might have elected to structure the narrative this way. The two stories share some thematic concerns, each featuring a woman who leaves home while carrying home with her. The two women move through the same territory in opposite directions, their trajectories overlapping without ever intersecting, like lines on a page. One woman sees the territory as "less a home than a delay in some unknown course," which could just as well describe the novel itself, for it constantly delays the delivery of the story even beyond the final line: "She has just begun the story, and there is still so much to tell."
There are many things I appreciate about this book. The prose is lovely even when the stream-of-consciousness style is difficult to follow, and Harmon's ability to build the narrative out of a variety of materials from myth to maps to local gossip creates a rich fictional world that seems to exist simultaneously in the realms of fairy tale and journalism.
And yet: I miss the story. Harmon writes for the kind of reader who considers straightforward narrative and character development passe; he eschews or obscures plot to the point that the story gets lost beneath its own impressive machinery. At one point the main character (about whom we know little more than we know about any other character) recalls an earlier conversation: "Every man tells the tale of his life, he had said, and she answered And every woman must listen. But who will tell mine?"
I've been listening carefully for two weeks and 225 page, and I'm still looking for that story.
The blacktop has buckled. The car jolts. Roots from these tall trees
and roof of her house were to be sawed into pieces, broken apart
have stretched beneath the road; water has seeped through the bed of
by crowbars, raised on jacks, liften onto flatbed trucks and driven
gravel and sand, and frozen during the winters; spring thaws have
six and a half miles southwest....
weakened the road's edges....
So begins the last section of Joshua Harmon's Quinnehtukqut, a book I've been alternately breezing and struggling through for two weeks now. This last section consists of two separate stories, one in normal type and one in italic, presented in alternating lines for more than 30 pages. It took me a while to figure out how to read these pages; I finally settled on reading the plain type all the way through and then starting over on the italics. I suppose it would be possible to simply read straight down the page as if these were lines of poetry, but this reading method obscures the narrative. Of course, that may be the point.
I can see several reasons Harmon might have elected to structure the narrative this way. The two stories share some thematic concerns, each featuring a woman who leaves home while carrying home with her. The two women move through the same territory in opposite directions, their trajectories overlapping without ever intersecting, like lines on a page. One woman sees the territory as "less a home than a delay in some unknown course," which could just as well describe the novel itself, for it constantly delays the delivery of the story even beyond the final line: "She has just begun the story, and there is still so much to tell."
There are many things I appreciate about this book. The prose is lovely even when the stream-of-consciousness style is difficult to follow, and Harmon's ability to build the narrative out of a variety of materials from myth to maps to local gossip creates a rich fictional world that seems to exist simultaneously in the realms of fairy tale and journalism.
And yet: I miss the story. Harmon writes for the kind of reader who considers straightforward narrative and character development passe; he eschews or obscures plot to the point that the story gets lost beneath its own impressive machinery. At one point the main character (about whom we know little more than we know about any other character) recalls an earlier conversation: "Every man tells the tale of his life, he had said, and she answered And every woman must listen. But who will tell mine?"
I've been listening carefully for two weeks and 225 page, and I'm still looking for that story.
What the well-dressed corpse is wearing
I've just finished reading the New Yorker Style issue, and the one thing I've learned from the Style issue is that I don't know anything about style. Not sure I want to know either. Let's look, for instance, at an ad on page 75: the model wears a loose yellow something, maybe a lab coat that got dumped in the wrong load of laundry, and she clutches a silver bag that looks like a half-deflated mylar balloon. Her hands and face are dead white, and her eye-shadow--well, imagine if a small child decided to make up her face with a yellow highlighter pen. Overall, the model appears prepared to play the role of the corpse in an episode of CSI. She'd be a stylish corpse, but who wants to be a corpse?
Awful bags are everywhere. Here on page 45 is a Bally ad featuring a sleek dark-haired model tenderly caressing a bag resembling Grandma's sensible pocketbook on steroids. This is the bag for the stylish, sophisticated Woman About Town who simply cannot set foot out the door without the Oxford English Dictionary, a chainsaw, and a side of beef. Three similarly awful bags appear on page 35, where the model is stylishly posed like an accident victim awaiting triage, her belongings scattered on the pavement around her. What is the message of this ad? "Carry our bags so you'll look stylish when you get hit by a crosstown bus!"
Let us turn the page: here we see a single Cole Haan shoe, strappy and sexy with heels up to here, a "state of the art high heel created in collaboration with Nike Lab." The perfect shoe for the athlete who doesn't intend to use her feet much longer. And here on page 31 is a Jil Sander ad featuring a model wearing a shapeless green shower curtain that perfectly matches her green high heels. She's all set for the St. Patrick's Day Parade, but I don't know where else one would wear such an ensemble.
A Max Mara ad on page 41 presents us with a woman ready to argue her case before the Supreme Court in her dark pin-striped suit, except her eyebrows look like they're about to take flight and her hair sticks straight up in the air and then flares out like the plumage on a creature designed by Dr. Seuss. Thankfully, she's not carrying a ridiculous bag. Instead, her chief accessory is a pair of hands attached to another woman who appears to be wrapped in mylar.
My favorite ensemble, though, is featured in a Fendi ad on page 29. The bag looks like a computer component and the shoes look like skyscrapers, but it took me a long time to figure out what the dress resembles. Where have I seen that shape before? It's white and folded like an envelope, and the model is certainly thin enough to slide into an envelope, but there's something else, some other common item suggested by that unusual combination of crisp folds and angles--and suddenly I'm remembering all those years I spent folding and changing and laundering cloth diapers. Yes: Fendi is showing a model swathed in a high-end embroidered diaper! With a bag to match!
It's not big enough to be a diaper bag, but she could always borrow the immense Gucci sack on the previous page.
Awful bags are everywhere. Here on page 45 is a Bally ad featuring a sleek dark-haired model tenderly caressing a bag resembling Grandma's sensible pocketbook on steroids. This is the bag for the stylish, sophisticated Woman About Town who simply cannot set foot out the door without the Oxford English Dictionary, a chainsaw, and a side of beef. Three similarly awful bags appear on page 35, where the model is stylishly posed like an accident victim awaiting triage, her belongings scattered on the pavement around her. What is the message of this ad? "Carry our bags so you'll look stylish when you get hit by a crosstown bus!"
Let us turn the page: here we see a single Cole Haan shoe, strappy and sexy with heels up to here, a "state of the art high heel created in collaboration with Nike Lab." The perfect shoe for the athlete who doesn't intend to use her feet much longer. And here on page 31 is a Jil Sander ad featuring a model wearing a shapeless green shower curtain that perfectly matches her green high heels. She's all set for the St. Patrick's Day Parade, but I don't know where else one would wear such an ensemble.
A Max Mara ad on page 41 presents us with a woman ready to argue her case before the Supreme Court in her dark pin-striped suit, except her eyebrows look like they're about to take flight and her hair sticks straight up in the air and then flares out like the plumage on a creature designed by Dr. Seuss. Thankfully, she's not carrying a ridiculous bag. Instead, her chief accessory is a pair of hands attached to another woman who appears to be wrapped in mylar.
My favorite ensemble, though, is featured in a Fendi ad on page 29. The bag looks like a computer component and the shoes look like skyscrapers, but it took me a long time to figure out what the dress resembles. Where have I seen that shape before? It's white and folded like an envelope, and the model is certainly thin enough to slide into an envelope, but there's something else, some other common item suggested by that unusual combination of crisp folds and angles--and suddenly I'm remembering all those years I spent folding and changing and laundering cloth diapers. Yes: Fendi is showing a model swathed in a high-end embroidered diaper! With a bag to match!
It's not big enough to be a diaper bag, but she could always borrow the immense Gucci sack on the previous page.
Friday, March 16, 2007
Quoth the buzzard?
Yesterday we were walking down the driveway when we saw buzzards circling just over our heads, at least a dozen big black ones with gray-white wingtips; they circled and circled and then went away. We see buzzards often, but never that many at once. What would Poe make of such a portentous visitation?
The bearded wonder saw an indigo bunting near the woods earlier this week, and every time I go out I hear new birdcalls sounding like a soundtrack in a Tarzan movie. Something is happening, I tell you. It could be spring! Maybe that's what the buzzards were looking for.
The bearded wonder saw an indigo bunting near the woods earlier this week, and every time I go out I hear new birdcalls sounding like a soundtrack in a Tarzan movie. Something is happening, I tell you. It could be spring! Maybe that's what the buzzards were looking for.
Thursday, March 15, 2007
Atonement, authorial and otherwise
Early yesterday I read a line on page 5 of a 350-page book, and by midnight I had finished the book. Here is the line that caught my attention: "Whereas her big sister's room was a stew of unclosed books, unfolded clothes, unmade bed, unemptied ashtrays, Briony's was a shrine to her controlling demon: the model farm spread across a deep window ledge consisted of the usual animals, but all facing one way--toward their owner--as if about to break into song, and even the farmyard hens were neatly corralled."
That little girl's carefully maintained shrine to herself soon comes crumbling down in exquisite slow motion stretching over the first third of the book. The book is Atonement by Ian McEwen, published in 2001, which makes me wonder how I've missed out on McEwen's work for so long. I have lots of friends whose opinions I respect, but not one of them ever grasped me by the lapel while insistently whispering McEwen's name in my ear or, better yet, sent me a McEwen novel for Christmas. Where are my friends when I need them? Someone must pay for those six lost years! Someone must provide atonement!
That someone will not be the author of the book within the book, who, late in life, attempts to assess her authorial responsibility: "how can a novelist achieve atonement when, with her absolute power of deciding outcomes, she is also God? There is no one, no entity or higher form that she can appeal to, or be reconciled with, or that can forgive her. There is nothing outside her. In her imagation she has set the limits and the terms. No atonement for God, or novelists, even if they are atheists."
Earlier, the same character agonized over a rejection letter that painfully opened her eyes to the chief fault in her writing: "Did she really think she could hide behind some borrowed notions of modern writing, and drown her guilt in a stream--three streams!--of consciousness? The evasions of her little novel were exactly those of her life. Everything she did not wish to confront was also missing from her novella--and was necessary to it."
This passage perfectly describes a less satisfying reading experience I had recently--in fact, two of them! But that rant will have to wait for another day. For now, I'm atoning for my past neglect by finding some more books by Ian McEwen.
That little girl's carefully maintained shrine to herself soon comes crumbling down in exquisite slow motion stretching over the first third of the book. The book is Atonement by Ian McEwen, published in 2001, which makes me wonder how I've missed out on McEwen's work for so long. I have lots of friends whose opinions I respect, but not one of them ever grasped me by the lapel while insistently whispering McEwen's name in my ear or, better yet, sent me a McEwen novel for Christmas. Where are my friends when I need them? Someone must pay for those six lost years! Someone must provide atonement!
That someone will not be the author of the book within the book, who, late in life, attempts to assess her authorial responsibility: "how can a novelist achieve atonement when, with her absolute power of deciding outcomes, she is also God? There is no one, no entity or higher form that she can appeal to, or be reconciled with, or that can forgive her. There is nothing outside her. In her imagation she has set the limits and the terms. No atonement for God, or novelists, even if they are atheists."
Earlier, the same character agonized over a rejection letter that painfully opened her eyes to the chief fault in her writing: "Did she really think she could hide behind some borrowed notions of modern writing, and drown her guilt in a stream--three streams!--of consciousness? The evasions of her little novel were exactly those of her life. Everything she did not wish to confront was also missing from her novella--and was necessary to it."
This passage perfectly describes a less satisfying reading experience I had recently--in fact, two of them! But that rant will have to wait for another day. For now, I'm atoning for my past neglect by finding some more books by Ian McEwen.
Wednesday, March 14, 2007
Low-speed chase
Big news on the front page of the local paper: "Council to pursue house."
Sedentary they may be, but even our city council members ought to be able to overtake a house in a close pursuit. First, of course, they will have to debate the virtues of various methods of house pursuit: squad cars with lights and sirens or unmarked vehicles? The equine unit will want to get into the act, and the drug-sniffing dogs will bow out only after the mayor gets serious and tosses a few frisbees. Money will have to be appropriated from the proper budget line, and the minute the cost estimate hits the papers, citizens will begin forming protest groups: Citizens Opposed to the Unrestrained Pursuit of Houses (COUGH) will demand that the city council cough up proof of a conspiracy to deplete the municipal budget, while the PAID brigade (Pursue All Intransigent Domiciles) will demand that the council quadruple the funds devoted to the speedy pursuit of houses. Unwilling to face such a fight in an election year, the mayor will wisely decide to appoint a special commission to study issues related to house pursuit, which will report its findings long after the November election.
Meanwhile, the house in question will continue to inch its way out of the city council's peripheral vision. By the time the council straps on its running shoes to begin the pursuit, the house will be working as a fry cook in a run-down section of St. Louis.
Sedentary they may be, but even our city council members ought to be able to overtake a house in a close pursuit. First, of course, they will have to debate the virtues of various methods of house pursuit: squad cars with lights and sirens or unmarked vehicles? The equine unit will want to get into the act, and the drug-sniffing dogs will bow out only after the mayor gets serious and tosses a few frisbees. Money will have to be appropriated from the proper budget line, and the minute the cost estimate hits the papers, citizens will begin forming protest groups: Citizens Opposed to the Unrestrained Pursuit of Houses (COUGH) will demand that the city council cough up proof of a conspiracy to deplete the municipal budget, while the PAID brigade (Pursue All Intransigent Domiciles) will demand that the council quadruple the funds devoted to the speedy pursuit of houses. Unwilling to face such a fight in an election year, the mayor will wisely decide to appoint a special commission to study issues related to house pursuit, which will report its findings long after the November election.
Meanwhile, the house in question will continue to inch its way out of the city council's peripheral vision. By the time the council straps on its running shoes to begin the pursuit, the house will be working as a fry cook in a run-down section of St. Louis.
When good essays go bad
A midterm essay informs me that "Religious morels and values greatly change a person's life." When fungi find faith, there's hope for us all. Well, most of us, anyway.
I've just finished reading midterm essay exams, and overall, I'm pleased. Every student wrote an actual essay, which is a big improvement over past years, when some students saw the words "essay exam" as an excuse to toss a mess of unconnected insights onto the page. Some of the essays are quite good, and most are competent. However, I'm a little concerned about a small group of students who wrote pretty good essays that simply failed to meet the requirements for the assignment.
This happened in a freshman composition class that has been focusing intensely on properly incorporating material from sources into their own writing. The midterm exam asked students to write an essay in response to a particular question, drawing evidence from two of the essays they've read for class in the past three weeks. I had told them in advance that they should bring their textbooks because I expected them to use and document quotations from the readings, and the midterm exam assignment sheet specifically stated that they were required to use quotations and paraphrases from the two essays in question and to document them properly.
Most students demonstrated at least some acquaintance with the two essays and incorporated information from them with varying degrees of competence. One student, however, wrote a very interesting and creative essay that had nothing to do with the two readings and included a bogus Works Cited entry for the student's own encyclopedic knowledge of the topic. Three other students wrote fairly competent essays in which they vaguely referred to the two readings but included no solid information, no quotations, and no documentation. Did they ignore the instructions, or did they forget to buy the textbook?
What kind of thought process leads a student to spend an hour writing an essay that demonstrates little or no relationship to the assignment? Do they think that I just won't notice that they haven't fulfilled the requirements? Or do they hope to charm me with their sparkling prose? It's true that I am reluctant to write an F on a well-written essay, but what else can I do? Using and documenting quotations was a major component of this assignment, and these students simply failed to do that. And if they paid so little attention to the assignment sheet, how much attention will they pay to the helpful comments I write on their essays?
What these students need is a life-changing experience. Where are those religious morels when you need them?
I've just finished reading midterm essay exams, and overall, I'm pleased. Every student wrote an actual essay, which is a big improvement over past years, when some students saw the words "essay exam" as an excuse to toss a mess of unconnected insights onto the page. Some of the essays are quite good, and most are competent. However, I'm a little concerned about a small group of students who wrote pretty good essays that simply failed to meet the requirements for the assignment.
This happened in a freshman composition class that has been focusing intensely on properly incorporating material from sources into their own writing. The midterm exam asked students to write an essay in response to a particular question, drawing evidence from two of the essays they've read for class in the past three weeks. I had told them in advance that they should bring their textbooks because I expected them to use and document quotations from the readings, and the midterm exam assignment sheet specifically stated that they were required to use quotations and paraphrases from the two essays in question and to document them properly.
Most students demonstrated at least some acquaintance with the two essays and incorporated information from them with varying degrees of competence. One student, however, wrote a very interesting and creative essay that had nothing to do with the two readings and included a bogus Works Cited entry for the student's own encyclopedic knowledge of the topic. Three other students wrote fairly competent essays in which they vaguely referred to the two readings but included no solid information, no quotations, and no documentation. Did they ignore the instructions, or did they forget to buy the textbook?
What kind of thought process leads a student to spend an hour writing an essay that demonstrates little or no relationship to the assignment? Do they think that I just won't notice that they haven't fulfilled the requirements? Or do they hope to charm me with their sparkling prose? It's true that I am reluctant to write an F on a well-written essay, but what else can I do? Using and documenting quotations was a major component of this assignment, and these students simply failed to do that. And if they paid so little attention to the assignment sheet, how much attention will they pay to the helpful comments I write on their essays?
What these students need is a life-changing experience. Where are those religious morels when you need them?
Tuesday, March 13, 2007
Here comes the sun
I write today not to celebrate the first robin of spring or the first sighting of a red-winged blackbird; instead, I look in the mirror and celebrate sunburn. Where there is sunburn, there is sunshine, which suggests that winter is finally on the way out. The juncos are still hanging around as if they're awaiting that last arctic blast of the season and thick icicles still cling stubbornly to the north-facing bluff across the road, but the temperature reached 75 degrees Farenheit today on my deck, with a warm, gentle breeze blowing away the debris of winter.
I wiped off the deck chairs and served lunch to friends outside, with a result plainly visible on my face. It's not a bad burn--no pain, no itching--but it's a helpful reminder that more warmth is on the way. Others may crow about the return of the robins, but me? I celebrate sunburn as a sign of spring.
I wiped off the deck chairs and served lunch to friends outside, with a result plainly visible on my face. It's not a bad burn--no pain, no itching--but it's a helpful reminder that more warmth is on the way. Others may crow about the return of the robins, but me? I celebrate sunburn as a sign of spring.
Monday, March 12, 2007
Cold feet
About shoes I'm sure I have written. Zucchini likewise, and perhaps even zucchini in the freezer. However, one topic on which I am certain I have never written is "stretching shoes with zucchini in the freezer"; nevertheless, that search string brought some poor misguided soul to this site. I don't know how (or why) to stretch shoes with zucchini in the freezer, but I"m sure someone out there does. That is the wonder of the Internet: the committed zucchini-shoe-stretcher need never fear being alone in the world, for if there is one person out there devoted to stretching shoes with zucchini in the freezer, Google is certain to lead him or her here.
The latest crop of search queries leading to this site is bulging with pleas for help with mice in oven insulation, also a topic I've never discussed, although I've certainly dealt with mice elsewhere. Others are seeking a recipe for kohlrabi soup or solutions for "turnips, glut of," and my only suggestion is this: don't give them to my husband.
Many many people arrived here while searching for cheat sheets for Excelsior College exams, while others want a short-cut to literary analysis for "Griffy the Cooper" or "Under the Lion's Paw." I would like to go after these people with the "pink chipmunk rifle" that brought another searcher here. Far be it from me to wish on such searchers a case of "Sticky eyeball melted the sun," which brought another seeker here.
I was pleased to see that someone came here while searching for "Me, Little Geisha Girl," an annoying song that has been running through my head since my last dance recital nearly 40 years ago. Now if Google could just tell me how to remove annoying songs from my head, we'd be getting somewhere.
Not here, though. Some questions I simply cannot answer.
The latest crop of search queries leading to this site is bulging with pleas for help with mice in oven insulation, also a topic I've never discussed, although I've certainly dealt with mice elsewhere. Others are seeking a recipe for kohlrabi soup or solutions for "turnips, glut of," and my only suggestion is this: don't give them to my husband.
Many many people arrived here while searching for cheat sheets for Excelsior College exams, while others want a short-cut to literary analysis for "Griffy the Cooper" or "Under the Lion's Paw." I would like to go after these people with the "pink chipmunk rifle" that brought another searcher here. Far be it from me to wish on such searchers a case of "Sticky eyeball melted the sun," which brought another seeker here.
I was pleased to see that someone came here while searching for "Me, Little Geisha Girl," an annoying song that has been running through my head since my last dance recital nearly 40 years ago. Now if Google could just tell me how to remove annoying songs from my head, we'd be getting somewhere.
Not here, though. Some questions I simply cannot answer.
Saturday, March 10, 2007
Mutants R Us
In the March 12 New Yorker, Anthony Lane's article "Down by the River" starts like this:
How come we get so many films about serial killers, teen-age libidos, and the Second World War, but nothing about giant mutant tadpoles? The imbalance has always struck me as unjust, and some of us have considered forming a pressure group to lobby for the inclusion of giant mutant tadpoles in mainstream cinema. Now the pressure is off, thanks to "The Host."
What would you call that pressure group? People for the Cinematic Treatment of Mutant Tadpoles?
It's a wonderful article. Whether it's a wonderful movie remains to be seen.
How come we get so many films about serial killers, teen-age libidos, and the Second World War, but nothing about giant mutant tadpoles? The imbalance has always struck me as unjust, and some of us have considered forming a pressure group to lobby for the inclusion of giant mutant tadpoles in mainstream cinema. Now the pressure is off, thanks to "The Host."
What would you call that pressure group? People for the Cinematic Treatment of Mutant Tadpoles?
It's a wonderful article. Whether it's a wonderful movie remains to be seen.
Friday, March 09, 2007
Invasion of the pizza snatchers
We were eating supper at a cheap pizza restaurant--one of those places where the kitchen workers yell incomprehensible comments every time a new type of pizza is placed on the counter--when I saw before me something truly reprehensible. I have nothing against inventive pizza toppings. I have eaten potato pizza and shrimp pizza, and I have no fear of olives, anchovies, or feta cheese. This pizza, however, takes the cake, for piled high on that crusty pie was a steaming mound of macaroni and cheese.
"Two-year-olds have taken over the kitchen! Run for your lives!" is what I wanted to say, but instead I sat there silently and watched a dozen greedy, grasping hands polish off that pizza. We all have our limits, and I guess I've found mine. This is where I nail my theses to the kitchen door: we must stop the sales of such indulgences! By allowing toddlers' tastes to rule our kitchens, we sell our birthright for a mess of pottage-a-roni! I stand before that steaming mass of gooey macaroni and loudly proclaim, 'Thus far and no further!"
But alas, no one can hear me over the sound of their chewing.
"Two-year-olds have taken over the kitchen! Run for your lives!" is what I wanted to say, but instead I sat there silently and watched a dozen greedy, grasping hands polish off that pizza. We all have our limits, and I guess I've found mine. This is where I nail my theses to the kitchen door: we must stop the sales of such indulgences! By allowing toddlers' tastes to rule our kitchens, we sell our birthright for a mess of pottage-a-roni! I stand before that steaming mass of gooey macaroni and loudly proclaim, 'Thus far and no further!"
But alas, no one can hear me over the sound of their chewing.
Obliviously obvious
Hot news! Be prepared for an insight that will knock your socks off: I have just read (and I can hardly believe my good fortune!) that "poetry means different things to different people and it is up to the individual reader to interpret."
Yes! In fact, this insight is so amazing that it appears, in slightly different forms, in roughly half of the poetry papers on my desk this morning! Some papers claim that it's up to the individual reader to "interrupt," but let's not get picky! The astounding thing is that on several occasions in class I have actually used this remarkable insight as an example of a sentence I do not EVER want to see in a student paper!!!!
I'd better settle down and take a deep breath before I use up my quota of exclamation points. Let's just all agree, once and for all, that poetry means different things to different people and it is up to the individual reader to interpret (or interrupt, as the case may be). There: it's down in black and white for everyone to see. No one ever needs to say it again, especially not in an analytical essay, and most especially not in my class.
Likewise, no one ever needs to write that "people should follow their own dreams" or "some feel one way about the issue and some feel another way and it's up to the individual to decide." And while we're at it, my wonderful colleague Janet doesn't want to see any more freshman essays starting with "In today's society" or that thrilling alternative, "In society today." Neither do we want to see a three-page essay that begins with "Since the beginning of time" or "Throughout history." A three-page essay that promises to survey the course of an idea since the beginning ot time is making a promise it cannot possibly keep.
Since the beginning of time, teachers have been complaining about annoyingly obvious statements that pop up repeatedly in student papers, but in today's society, I feel strongly that we should do more than complain. Some feel one way about the issue and some feel another way, and it is up to the reader to decide whether to ignore this rant or send in an example of his or her own most annoying statement from student papers. We could create some found poetry from the collection, which would mean different things to different people, and then we could burn the collection in a ritual bonfire. But everyone should follow their own dreams!
Yes! In fact, this insight is so amazing that it appears, in slightly different forms, in roughly half of the poetry papers on my desk this morning! Some papers claim that it's up to the individual reader to "interrupt," but let's not get picky! The astounding thing is that on several occasions in class I have actually used this remarkable insight as an example of a sentence I do not EVER want to see in a student paper!!!!
I'd better settle down and take a deep breath before I use up my quota of exclamation points. Let's just all agree, once and for all, that poetry means different things to different people and it is up to the individual reader to interpret (or interrupt, as the case may be). There: it's down in black and white for everyone to see. No one ever needs to say it again, especially not in an analytical essay, and most especially not in my class.
Likewise, no one ever needs to write that "people should follow their own dreams" or "some feel one way about the issue and some feel another way and it's up to the individual to decide." And while we're at it, my wonderful colleague Janet doesn't want to see any more freshman essays starting with "In today's society" or that thrilling alternative, "In society today." Neither do we want to see a three-page essay that begins with "Since the beginning of time" or "Throughout history." A three-page essay that promises to survey the course of an idea since the beginning ot time is making a promise it cannot possibly keep.
Since the beginning of time, teachers have been complaining about annoyingly obvious statements that pop up repeatedly in student papers, but in today's society, I feel strongly that we should do more than complain. Some feel one way about the issue and some feel another way, and it is up to the reader to decide whether to ignore this rant or send in an example of his or her own most annoying statement from student papers. We could create some found poetry from the collection, which would mean different things to different people, and then we could burn the collection in a ritual bonfire. But everyone should follow their own dreams!
Thursday, March 08, 2007
Powerless: The Aftermath
In addition to a power outage, for the past two days some of my students have been suffering from a time outage, or so they say. I don't know how many times today I've heard some variation on the following plea: "I didn't have time to study because of the power outage so I assume the midterm exam will be postponed."
Okay, let's review: for the past two days students have had no classes to worry about, but somehow that added up to less time to study for the midterm. In my math, less time in class = more time for studying. Maybe my students are using a different kind of math--or maybe when that transformer blew out it caused some serious damage to the space-time continuum.
Yes, midterm exams will be given as scheduled. I e-mailed all my students Tuesday and Wednesday to provide some information about their exams and suggest some strategies for preparation, but of course some of them had trouble accessing their e-mail with the power absent from some parts of campus. Most of my students used their noggins to overcome this disadvantage, discovering that there are many ways to access college e-mail even during a power outage. Others did not. Perhaps they suffered from an ingenuity outage.
Today everything seems to be back to normal: the lights are on, the heat is up, and computers are humming in the background. Time-out is over, people! Let's take those brain cells out for a spin!
Okay, let's review: for the past two days students have had no classes to worry about, but somehow that added up to less time to study for the midterm. In my math, less time in class = more time for studying. Maybe my students are using a different kind of math--or maybe when that transformer blew out it caused some serious damage to the space-time continuum.
Yes, midterm exams will be given as scheduled. I e-mailed all my students Tuesday and Wednesday to provide some information about their exams and suggest some strategies for preparation, but of course some of them had trouble accessing their e-mail with the power absent from some parts of campus. Most of my students used their noggins to overcome this disadvantage, discovering that there are many ways to access college e-mail even during a power outage. Others did not. Perhaps they suffered from an ingenuity outage.
Today everything seems to be back to normal: the lights are on, the heat is up, and computers are humming in the background. Time-out is over, people! Let's take those brain cells out for a spin!
Wednesday, March 07, 2007
Powerless, Part 2
Before 7:00 this morning three different people called to tell me to stay home because the power is still out on campus and classes are cancelled. Apparently the rented generator that provided heat for some of the dorms last night malfunctioned and the power company is still working on replacing the transformer that blew out Tuesday. I've been frantically e-mailing my students to prepare them for the midterm exams they'll be taking Thursday and Friday, but some students still don't have access to e-mail so I don't know how effective my messages will be. I was just thinking about driving to campus to pick up whatever papers students might have managed to turn in yesterday, but suddenly it's snowing, big fluffy flakes pouring from the sky like an urgent message from God.
I can take a hint. I'm staying home.
I can take a hint. I'm staying home.
Tuesday, March 06, 2007
Powerless
I was in my office preparing for my 8:00 class this morning when a student called to ask if we would be having class today. "Why wouldn't we be having class today?" I asked. That's when I found out that the power was out.
Well, not entirely. My office had power enough to provide light but not enough to run my computer or boil water for tea, and it was only after I spoke to my student that I noticed how cold it was. Apparently a transformer blew out yesterday and most of the campus has been lacking light, heat, and power all night.
All classes were cancelled, naturally, but my students knew this before I did. I spent some time calling my colleagues, waking them up only to tell them to go back to bed. They were delighted. I was not. I had things to do in today's classes! Important things! How will we ever get caught up?!!!
But I got over it. I thought about staying on campus and doing some work in my office, but my policy is "No heat, no tea, no service." Instead, I did some shopping and then came home and put a pot roast in the crock pot. I can get online at home, which is more than I could do in my office. This afternoon I'll enjoy the comforts of home: heat, light, hot tea, and pot roast. Tomorrow we'll all be back to business as usual.
Well, not entirely. My office had power enough to provide light but not enough to run my computer or boil water for tea, and it was only after I spoke to my student that I noticed how cold it was. Apparently a transformer blew out yesterday and most of the campus has been lacking light, heat, and power all night.
All classes were cancelled, naturally, but my students knew this before I did. I spent some time calling my colleagues, waking them up only to tell them to go back to bed. They were delighted. I was not. I had things to do in today's classes! Important things! How will we ever get caught up?!!!
But I got over it. I thought about staying on campus and doing some work in my office, but my policy is "No heat, no tea, no service." Instead, I did some shopping and then came home and put a pot roast in the crock pot. I can get online at home, which is more than I could do in my office. This afternoon I'll enjoy the comforts of home: heat, light, hot tea, and pot roast. Tomorrow we'll all be back to business as usual.
Monday, March 05, 2007
My MISFIT
"The personal essay is an excuse for bad fiction-writers to publish." So said Eric Miles Williamson, editor of Pleiades, at one of the conference sessions I attended last week. I'm not sure what use to make of that statement, but I must have felt it was important because I wrote it down in my notebook, along with this from the same source: "If you want to get a bad story published, call it an essay."
After three days in Atlanta, my notebook is full of such little nuggets of--well, I don't know whether "wisdom" is the right word. I know it's not terribly wise to write down all these notes and haul them home if I'm not going to make anything of them, so today I think I'll make a Miscellany of Ideas that Seemed Fairly Important at the Time (MISFIT):
I'm already tired of the word "poignant." (Source: me, after only half a day of conferencing!)
Eighty percent of what we need to know about writing fiction comes from poetry. (Source: Walter Mosley, who dressed dramatically all in black--black suit, black dress shirt, black hat, black high-top sneakers--and also said that history is a lie but writing a novel is our best chance to get to the truth.)
Picture a thousand poets trying to shove into the same elevator while mumbling the mantra "my publisher, my publisher" and you will have a good sense of the scene in the Hilton lobby Friday night. (Source: me, with a little help from my friends.)
"Etiquette is the death of religion." (Source: someone on a panel about writing faith for the faithless, which attracted a standing-room-only crowd roughly evenly divided between those who looked like Mormon missionaries and those who looked like they'd just dropped in after a long morning of threshing wheat at the Holistic Living Commune, except it's the wrong time of year to be threshing wheat.)
That's about it. Everything else is either illegible or incoherent. I suppose I could put all these insights together and call it a personal essay, but what would Eric Miles Williamson think?
After three days in Atlanta, my notebook is full of such little nuggets of--well, I don't know whether "wisdom" is the right word. I know it's not terribly wise to write down all these notes and haul them home if I'm not going to make anything of them, so today I think I'll make a Miscellany of Ideas that Seemed Fairly Important at the Time (MISFIT):
I'm already tired of the word "poignant." (Source: me, after only half a day of conferencing!)
Eighty percent of what we need to know about writing fiction comes from poetry. (Source: Walter Mosley, who dressed dramatically all in black--black suit, black dress shirt, black hat, black high-top sneakers--and also said that history is a lie but writing a novel is our best chance to get to the truth.)
Picture a thousand poets trying to shove into the same elevator while mumbling the mantra "my publisher, my publisher" and you will have a good sense of the scene in the Hilton lobby Friday night. (Source: me, with a little help from my friends.)
"Etiquette is the death of religion." (Source: someone on a panel about writing faith for the faithless, which attracted a standing-room-only crowd roughly evenly divided between those who looked like Mormon missionaries and those who looked like they'd just dropped in after a long morning of threshing wheat at the Holistic Living Commune, except it's the wrong time of year to be threshing wheat.)
That's about it. Everything else is either illegible or incoherent. I suppose I could put all these insights together and call it a personal essay, but what would Eric Miles Williamson think?
Saturday, March 03, 2007
Like a rolling stone
Today I had intended to make like a rolling stone, but instead I seem to be gathering moss. It started this morning at the Starbucks in my hotel, where I went through my daily chai-ordering ritual: I pronounce my name and the cashier mispronounces it; I say it again and she finds another way to mangle it; I either say it again or give up and accept the cashier's christening. Then the cashier conveys my order to the chai-maker: "Grande chai for Miss Bev" (or Beth or, this morning, Mauve), and the chai-maker writes on the cup a name that may or may not correspond with the moniker selected by the cashier. Then there's a moment of suspense as I wait to see what name the chai-maker will bestow upon me. Yesterday, through some bizarre conjunction of celestial objects, the cup said Bev, but Thursday it insisted on Beth, certainly the most common and forgiveable mangling of my name.
This morning my cup called me Moss. Nothing against Moss--I like moss, really; some of my best plants are moss--but how can I roll through the bookfair resisting booksellers' attempts to stick stuff on me if I resemble Moss?
I sat for a while at Starbuck's contemplating this dilemma before I finally tossed the cup in the can. Goodbye, Moss. This Bev is rolling.
This morning my cup called me Moss. Nothing against Moss--I like moss, really; some of my best plants are moss--but how can I roll through the bookfair resisting booksellers' attempts to stick stuff on me if I resemble Moss?
I sat for a while at Starbuck's contemplating this dilemma before I finally tossed the cup in the can. Goodbye, Moss. This Bev is rolling.
Friday, March 02, 2007
Safe at home?
We heard first thing this morning that a busload of baseball players from a small college in Ohio had crashed here in Atlanta, and we were a little alarmed. I thought of my 8:00 freshman composition class half full of baseball players and tried to remember where they were traveling this weekend, but then we heard that the crashed bus was from Bluffton College and we were relieved that the pain this time would not belong to us but to strangers, a selfish feeling to be sure.
Still, it feels awfully close to home. For four years I worked in Bluffton, not at the college itself but for a business where everyone was either an alumnus of Bluffton College or a parent of a student. This morning when we heard about the wreck, I ran through a mental roll call of former colleagues and tried to remember the ages of their children, praying for safety. It was too long ago and I am too far removed from that life, but I know that town and I feel their pain and I wish I could do something to help them. It's good to know my people are safe at home, but not so good to know that the ones who are not safe are my people too.
Still, it feels awfully close to home. For four years I worked in Bluffton, not at the college itself but for a business where everyone was either an alumnus of Bluffton College or a parent of a student. This morning when we heard about the wreck, I ran through a mental roll call of former colleagues and tried to remember the ages of their children, praying for safety. It was too long ago and I am too far removed from that life, but I know that town and I feel their pain and I wish I could do something to help them. It's good to know my people are safe at home, but not so good to know that the ones who are not safe are my people too.
Something to yell about
Our panel presented today, so naturally I had nightmares all night--the usual horrors about standing in front of a group of people I need to impress when suddenly my teeth start falling out, and I have to frantically try to catch the falling teeth while continuing with my presentation. This time the nightmare was enlivened by a visit from my dentist, who first yelled at me for letting my teeth fall out and then dragged my orthodontist into the room and started yelling at him. Then I started yelling back, except my yelling was not confined to dreamland. The longsuffering colleague in the next bed had to gently remind me that all that yelling was not really necessary at 2 a.m.
Nothing could go wrong during our panel that could possibly be worse than that nightmare, which, I suppose, is the point of the nightmare: if I've already survived the worst that could happen, the presentation itself will be smooth sailing. And indeed it was. There were some technical difficulties beforehand and we had to contend with a room cold enough to hang meat in, but all in all, it was an exhilarating experience. Last year in Atlanta I read a paper to an audience that can be described by the equation a = p +1, where a = the number of people in the audience and p = number of people on the panel. Today's audience was more robust, despite the fact that they had to sit on their hands to avoid frostbite.
Best of all, there was no yelling involved--and I still have all my teeth.
Nothing could go wrong during our panel that could possibly be worse than that nightmare, which, I suppose, is the point of the nightmare: if I've already survived the worst that could happen, the presentation itself will be smooth sailing. And indeed it was. There were some technical difficulties beforehand and we had to contend with a room cold enough to hang meat in, but all in all, it was an exhilarating experience. Last year in Atlanta I read a paper to an audience that can be described by the equation a = p +1, where a = the number of people in the audience and p = number of people on the panel. Today's audience was more robust, despite the fact that they had to sit on their hands to avoid frostbite.
Best of all, there was no yelling involved--and I still have all my teeth.
Thursday, March 01, 2007
Lost in the bookfair
I've just escaped from the conference bookfair for the second time. I venture bravely into the labyrinth of book-covered tables guarded by rabid booksellers and I wander around trying to impersonate an International Woman of Mystery in hopes that the booksellers will just let me look, but no. Next time I'll wear a necklace of garlic bulbs and lead a hyena on a leash. It's not enough that they try to lure me in with brightly-colored book covers featuring enigmatic titles; no, they offer treats too, T-shirts and chocolates and free sample issues of literary journals with names that sound like engine parts or children's games or self-consciously ironic cultural critique. When I start my literary magazine, I'll call it Drivel.
I keep my eyes and feet moving, hoping to glide smoothly through the aisles without attracting attention, but they pop up in front of me, these booksellers, to baffle my intentions. They all ask the same two questions:
1. Are you a writer?
2. What do you write?
Others seem to have ready answers for these questions, but I struggle: "Um, well, I write incisive comments on student papers and blog entries and annual assessment reports and book reviews and handouts and essays and limericks and things like that." Once when an eager bookseller asked me "Poetry or fiction?" I smiled brightly and said, "Yes!"
Finally I had to retreat, but not before buying a book--just one--despite the fact that a blurb on the back describes it as a "magical postmodern epic." Why did I buy it?
1. I like the cover photo.
2. I like the title.
3. I like the price ($8).
4. The author was standing right there ready to sign it.
It's called Quinnehtukqut, by the way, a novel by a guy I've never heard of called Joshua Harmon. He tells me the title is pronounced just like my home state--Connecticut--although the book is set in New Hampshire. The cover photo shows Harmon's great-grandfather in a flannel shirt and grimy dungarees, standing on a streetcorner and smoking a cigarette. Here is a sentence selected at random from the top of page 41: "A midwinter barn dance and that Hennessy girl as sour as old milk."
Magical? We'll see. Walking out of a room full of high-pressure booksellers with only one book is a remarkable feat in itself, but if that book can magically transport me away from this seething mass of intensely creative people, it will be eight dollars well spent.
I keep my eyes and feet moving, hoping to glide smoothly through the aisles without attracting attention, but they pop up in front of me, these booksellers, to baffle my intentions. They all ask the same two questions:
1. Are you a writer?
2. What do you write?
Others seem to have ready answers for these questions, but I struggle: "Um, well, I write incisive comments on student papers and blog entries and annual assessment reports and book reviews and handouts and essays and limericks and things like that." Once when an eager bookseller asked me "Poetry or fiction?" I smiled brightly and said, "Yes!"
Finally I had to retreat, but not before buying a book--just one--despite the fact that a blurb on the back describes it as a "magical postmodern epic." Why did I buy it?
1. I like the cover photo.
2. I like the title.
3. I like the price ($8).
4. The author was standing right there ready to sign it.
It's called Quinnehtukqut, by the way, a novel by a guy I've never heard of called Joshua Harmon. He tells me the title is pronounced just like my home state--Connecticut--although the book is set in New Hampshire. The cover photo shows Harmon's great-grandfather in a flannel shirt and grimy dungarees, standing on a streetcorner and smoking a cigarette. Here is a sentence selected at random from the top of page 41: "A midwinter barn dance and that Hennessy girl as sour as old milk."
Magical? We'll see. Walking out of a room full of high-pressure booksellers with only one book is a remarkable feat in itself, but if that book can magically transport me away from this seething mass of intensely creative people, it will be eight dollars well spent.
The Write Place
I'm in Atlanta now and my conference-going started this morning with a good sign: when I went to pick up my nametag at the registration area, the only desk that didn't have a long line in front of it was the one serving my portion of the alphabet. At that moment, I was the only G through L needing attention, and boy, did I get it.
My hotel is populated by attendees at two different conventions: a group of writers and writing teachers and a group of sales associates. It's easy to tell the two groups apart. For one thing, the sales associates sport fewer ponytails, and the writers are more likely to be dressed in costumes suggesting creativity, authenticity, and drama. The first session I attended (on syntax in poetry) was populated mostly by women, most of them middle-aged or older and looking very sincere. The session didn't start on time, but what did I expect from a gaggle of poets? "We don't know who we are, frankly," said the first speaker, and I sympathize. With many dozens of concurrent sessions running for three days, I don't see a single session for doggerelists. There is a session featuring a panelist talking about blogging--but wait, that would be me. Hope I'm not the only one interested in the topic.
And what about Bloggers Without Borders? There's a small Starbucks tucked into the lobby of the Marriott Marquis; I'll be there at 8:00 sharp Saturday, ready to encounter anyone out there who might want to visit. I'll be the girl with the orchid behind her ear. Or not.
My hotel is populated by attendees at two different conventions: a group of writers and writing teachers and a group of sales associates. It's easy to tell the two groups apart. For one thing, the sales associates sport fewer ponytails, and the writers are more likely to be dressed in costumes suggesting creativity, authenticity, and drama. The first session I attended (on syntax in poetry) was populated mostly by women, most of them middle-aged or older and looking very sincere. The session didn't start on time, but what did I expect from a gaggle of poets? "We don't know who we are, frankly," said the first speaker, and I sympathize. With many dozens of concurrent sessions running for three days, I don't see a single session for doggerelists. There is a session featuring a panelist talking about blogging--but wait, that would be me. Hope I'm not the only one interested in the topic.
And what about Bloggers Without Borders? There's a small Starbucks tucked into the lobby of the Marriott Marquis; I'll be there at 8:00 sharp Saturday, ready to encounter anyone out there who might want to visit. I'll be the girl with the orchid behind her ear. Or not.
Tuesday, February 27, 2007
Writing robots and grammar genes
I was still thinking about irregular verbs when I got home yesterday, so I decided to run the suspect sentence past my 17-year-old son. I asked him how he felt about this sentence: She laid naked on the bed.
"It should be lay," he said.
Then I asked, "Can you think of any context in which it would be appropriate to say 'She laid naked on the bed'?"
Without a pause he replied, "Only if it's talking about someone named Naked."
It's frightening the way that boy thinks. People are always telling me, "Of course your kid's a good writer; his mother's an English professor!" Or, "Of course he aced the SAT writing test! Look who his mother is!" As if he were just little remote-control writing robot responding to commands from my joystick. Do people really think I drill my children in irregular verbs at the dinner table and critique their journal entries on road trips? Or do they suspect me of spiking their Kool-Aid with secret herbal aids guaranteed to promote proper syntax?
The fact is that my son never lets me look at his writing. The only reason I know he's a good writer is that he sometimes accidentally leaves essays on my computer, where I exercise a mother's prerogative and read them. They're good, but I don't claim any credit for the fact that both of my children can wield words with creativity and grace. They grew up surrounded by books and learned to love reading, but their writing skills are solely their own. I certainly never drilled my son on the distinction between lie and lay, and if he cares enough about the language to have mastered that distinction, that's a testament to his talent and not mine.
On the other hand, maybe it's all genetic--in which case let's all congratulate ourselves for possessing good grammar genes, give up trying to teach our students the distinction between lie and lay, and dedicate the rest of our lives to promoting better grammar through eugenics.
You first.
"It should be lay," he said.
Then I asked, "Can you think of any context in which it would be appropriate to say 'She laid naked on the bed'?"
Without a pause he replied, "Only if it's talking about someone named Naked."
It's frightening the way that boy thinks. People are always telling me, "Of course your kid's a good writer; his mother's an English professor!" Or, "Of course he aced the SAT writing test! Look who his mother is!" As if he were just little remote-control writing robot responding to commands from my joystick. Do people really think I drill my children in irregular verbs at the dinner table and critique their journal entries on road trips? Or do they suspect me of spiking their Kool-Aid with secret herbal aids guaranteed to promote proper syntax?
The fact is that my son never lets me look at his writing. The only reason I know he's a good writer is that he sometimes accidentally leaves essays on my computer, where I exercise a mother's prerogative and read them. They're good, but I don't claim any credit for the fact that both of my children can wield words with creativity and grace. They grew up surrounded by books and learned to love reading, but their writing skills are solely their own. I certainly never drilled my son on the distinction between lie and lay, and if he cares enough about the language to have mastered that distinction, that's a testament to his talent and not mine.
On the other hand, maybe it's all genetic--in which case let's all congratulate ourselves for possessing good grammar genes, give up trying to teach our students the distinction between lie and lay, and dedicate the rest of our lives to promoting better grammar through eugenics.
You first.
Monday, February 26, 2007
Lie and lay: a little lesson
Suppose a woman--let's call her Sharon--has a cat with a bad skin disease resulting in the loss of fur, and suppose Sharon gets in the habit of calling that cat "Naked" instead of its given name, "Sultana." And suppose one day Sharon comes home to discover the cat called Naked lying sick on the cold tile floor, unable even to lift her head to meow "Hello." Sharon knows that Naked is not long for this world and she wants to make her departure as comfortable as possible, so she picks up the cat and sets her carefully on the bed. In this case it would be possible for someone writing about the situation to begin a story with the sentence, "She laid Naked on the bed." Laid is the past tense of lay, a transitive verb meaning "to set (something) down." Sharon set down the cat: laid is the word you want.
Now suppose Sharon, overcome with grief, decides to lie down next to her suffering cat. She pets Naked gently while the cat breathes its last breath, and then she says a little prayer for the repose of Naked's feline soul. She has no time to waste, however, because she knows her husband will soon arrive home from a long stint in Iraq and he would prefer his bed to hold a live wife than a dead cat. Dwayne has never cared for the cat; he wanted to have Naked put to sleep back when the first faint hints of the dreaded skin disease manifested themselves. Sharon had promised to put the cat to sleep after Dwayne left for Iraq, but she has not kept her promise, and now she must quickly compose herself so his first moments home from the war will be suitably welcoming. She wraps the dead cat and hides the body in the trunk of her car, and then she bustles about lighting candles and dressing in a little red satin skimpy thing. Some time later, when Dwayne finally remembers to ask her how long it's been since the cat died, she says, "Oh, months and months." In this case it is possible to begin a story with the sentence, "She lied naked in the bed." Lied is the past tense of lie, meaning "to tell an untruth." A naked Sharon told a lie about the cat: lied is word you want.
Suppose, though, that you want to begin a story about a naked woman who at some time in the past was recumbent on a bed. She is not telling an untruth and she is not setting something down; therefore, the verb you want is neither lay nor the form of lie meaning to tell an untruth. Instead, you want the form of lie that means "to recline." And what is the simple past tense of that form of lie? Why, lay, of course! Sharon might lie on the bed today, but sometime in the past, Sharon lay on the bed. She never laid on it unless she was setting something down, like the cat, Naked. Therefore, it would not be appropriate to begin a story with the sentence "Sharon laid naked on the bed"--unless you want to start all over again with that darn cat. Sharon lies on the bed today, but she lay naked on it yesterday, and she laid Naked the cat on it last week, and she might lie there speculating about where else at she might have laid the cat and how she might have lied about it, and whether she might have lain more easily at night if she had told Dwayne the simple truth.
See? It's not that difficult.
Now suppose Sharon, overcome with grief, decides to lie down next to her suffering cat. She pets Naked gently while the cat breathes its last breath, and then she says a little prayer for the repose of Naked's feline soul. She has no time to waste, however, because she knows her husband will soon arrive home from a long stint in Iraq and he would prefer his bed to hold a live wife than a dead cat. Dwayne has never cared for the cat; he wanted to have Naked put to sleep back when the first faint hints of the dreaded skin disease manifested themselves. Sharon had promised to put the cat to sleep after Dwayne left for Iraq, but she has not kept her promise, and now she must quickly compose herself so his first moments home from the war will be suitably welcoming. She wraps the dead cat and hides the body in the trunk of her car, and then she bustles about lighting candles and dressing in a little red satin skimpy thing. Some time later, when Dwayne finally remembers to ask her how long it's been since the cat died, she says, "Oh, months and months." In this case it is possible to begin a story with the sentence, "She lied naked in the bed." Lied is the past tense of lie, meaning "to tell an untruth." A naked Sharon told a lie about the cat: lied is word you want.
Suppose, though, that you want to begin a story about a naked woman who at some time in the past was recumbent on a bed. She is not telling an untruth and she is not setting something down; therefore, the verb you want is neither lay nor the form of lie meaning to tell an untruth. Instead, you want the form of lie that means "to recline." And what is the simple past tense of that form of lie? Why, lay, of course! Sharon might lie on the bed today, but sometime in the past, Sharon lay on the bed. She never laid on it unless she was setting something down, like the cat, Naked. Therefore, it would not be appropriate to begin a story with the sentence "Sharon laid naked on the bed"--unless you want to start all over again with that darn cat. Sharon lies on the bed today, but she lay naked on it yesterday, and she laid Naked the cat on it last week, and she might lie there speculating about where else at she might have laid the cat and how she might have lied about it, and whether she might have lain more easily at night if she had told Dwayne the simple truth.
See? It's not that difficult.
Sunday, February 25, 2007
Fighting Kung-Fu
We did a little channel-flipping tonight in an intrepid effort to avoid the Oscars, and somehow we stumbled on an episode of a classic of televised cheesiness: Kung-Fu, which was my adorable husband's favorite show back in the 1970s. An hour later, I can say that 1973 must have been a particularly bad year for both hair and dialogue. The resident 17-year-old, who had never seen Kung-Fu, took great pleasure in translating the old Asian guy's enigmatic pronouncements into Yoda-esque mystical insights. From deep within the Lazy-Boy would come the Yoda voice: "Every journey a beginning must have, and an ending must it come to."
My journeys this week should be fairly simple since the blizzard passed well north of here and the temperature appears to be rising. On Wednesday I leave for Atlanta, which means I'll spend the next two days frantically finishing things so I don't have to take a pile of work with me. The conference paper is written and the freshman essays are graded, but I still don't expect to have time to relax until I step onto the airplane--and who can relax on an airplane? I'll have to practice some deep breathing and focused visualizations, except that might lead me to envision an old blind Asian guy saying, "Can you snatch the pebble from my hand, Grasshopper?" When I'm trying to relax before takeoff, the last thing I want to envision is David Carradine with a bad haircut. That's one journey that never should have started.
My journeys this week should be fairly simple since the blizzard passed well north of here and the temperature appears to be rising. On Wednesday I leave for Atlanta, which means I'll spend the next two days frantically finishing things so I don't have to take a pile of work with me. The conference paper is written and the freshman essays are graded, but I still don't expect to have time to relax until I step onto the airplane--and who can relax on an airplane? I'll have to practice some deep breathing and focused visualizations, except that might lead me to envision an old blind Asian guy saying, "Can you snatch the pebble from my hand, Grasshopper?" When I'm trying to relax before takeoff, the last thing I want to envision is David Carradine with a bad haircut. That's one journey that never should have started.
Friday, February 23, 2007
Cracks in the ice
The sun is out and the snow has mostly melted, but our creek is experiencing a bit of a problem: all that thick ice broke up and drifted downstream until it hit our neighbor's low bridge, which is now holding back these huge chunks of ice that would really prefer to flow down to the river. Last night the temperature dipped low enough to let some of those ice chunks freeze together. You know Superman's Arctic hideaway with all those gigantic ice crystals sticking up at odd angles? That's what my creek looks like today.
That's also sort of what my life looks like right now. There's this big obstacle standing in the way of all my other projects, forcing them to stick out at odd angles in a vaguely menacing manner. I have two options: chip the oddly-shaped chunks into smaller pieces so they can move past the obstacle, or wait for a warm spell when everything starts to flow again. Today I've been doing a little chipping, a little waiting, a little more chipping, a little more waiting, and now I see the sun coming out ready to warm everything up and let it flow. One of these it will all flow freely again, but meanwhile, I'm lurking like Superman in his Arctic hideaway and gathering strength for the coming spring.
That's also sort of what my life looks like right now. There's this big obstacle standing in the way of all my other projects, forcing them to stick out at odd angles in a vaguely menacing manner. I have two options: chip the oddly-shaped chunks into smaller pieces so they can move past the obstacle, or wait for a warm spell when everything starts to flow again. Today I've been doing a little chipping, a little waiting, a little more chipping, a little more waiting, and now I see the sun coming out ready to warm everything up and let it flow. One of these it will all flow freely again, but meanwhile, I'm lurking like Superman in his Arctic hideaway and gathering strength for the coming spring.
Thursday, February 22, 2007
How to play with students' minds
It happens at about this time every semester: to give my composition students some exercise in using the MLA guide, I take a pile of books to class and give each to a group 0f students, who then have to figure out how to write a Works Cited listing for that source. I give them books with multiple authors or no author or an author and a translator or odd configurations of titles and subtitles, and I always include a book by Calvin Trillin called Deadline Poet: My Life as a Doggerelist. The group working on that book almost always leaves off the subtitle, which gives me a chance to add it to their citation, and then the class discussion proceeds something like this:
"Does anyone know what a doggerelist is?"
Dead silence.
"Nobody knows what doggerelist means?"
Silence.
"Does it help if I tell you I am a doggerelist?"
Silence accompanied by a few uncomfortable coughs and shuffles.
"Come on, what does doggerelist sound like?"
Finally, some brave soul says, "It sounds nasty."
This is when I smile broadly and explain what a doggerelist is--or not. Sometimes it's more fun to leave it to their imaginations.
I wonder: how many complaints would end up on the provost's desk if I just instructed all my students to go out and become doggerelists? It would almost be worth the experiment just to find out.
"Does anyone know what a doggerelist is?"
Dead silence.
"Nobody knows what doggerelist means?"
Silence.
"Does it help if I tell you I am a doggerelist?"
Silence accompanied by a few uncomfortable coughs and shuffles.
"Come on, what does doggerelist sound like?"
Finally, some brave soul says, "It sounds nasty."
This is when I smile broadly and explain what a doggerelist is--or not. Sometimes it's more fun to leave it to their imaginations.
I wonder: how many complaints would end up on the provost's desk if I just instructed all my students to go out and become doggerelists? It would almost be worth the experiment just to find out.
Wednesday, February 21, 2007
When A means F
Grade spread statistics for last semester have just come out, and it turns out that I give more A's than anyone else in our department--but I also give more F's. My overall grade average is on par with the departmental average, but it appears that I'm more willing to give high grades than the rest of my colleagues. I've been trying to figure out what this means.
The most optimistic interpretation is that I'm such a terrific teacher that more of my students learn the material and thereby earn higher grades, but that argument cuts both ways: if A's indicate good teaching, then what does that high number of F's indicate? Let's not go there.
I'm sure that my emphasis on writing as a process and my concomitant willingness to respond to multiple drafts is part of the reason. If students have many opportunities to improve their work, some of them will do so, and the improved work may well result in an improved grade--or a whole bunch of improved grades. However, I'm not the only one in my department who responds to multiple drafts, so that can't be the only reason.
Maybe I'm not demanding enough, or maybe I'm just a pushover. That's not what my students tell me, but what do they know? Maybe I need to adjust my expectations and grading rubrics to make an A more elusive. Of course, I'm reluctant to make a change based on one semester's data, especially since I taught two literature courses and only one section of composition last semester, which could have skewed the results slightly. I tend to give fewer A's in composition than in other courses, which raises a completely different set of questions. This semester I'm teaching two sections of composition and one literature course, so perhaps the spread will be different. Or not. And if it is (or isn't), what will that mean?
The final question is this: If A's indicate success, why do I see a high number of A's as some sort of failure?
The most optimistic interpretation is that I'm such a terrific teacher that more of my students learn the material and thereby earn higher grades, but that argument cuts both ways: if A's indicate good teaching, then what does that high number of F's indicate? Let's not go there.
I'm sure that my emphasis on writing as a process and my concomitant willingness to respond to multiple drafts is part of the reason. If students have many opportunities to improve their work, some of them will do so, and the improved work may well result in an improved grade--or a whole bunch of improved grades. However, I'm not the only one in my department who responds to multiple drafts, so that can't be the only reason.
Maybe I'm not demanding enough, or maybe I'm just a pushover. That's not what my students tell me, but what do they know? Maybe I need to adjust my expectations and grading rubrics to make an A more elusive. Of course, I'm reluctant to make a change based on one semester's data, especially since I taught two literature courses and only one section of composition last semester, which could have skewed the results slightly. I tend to give fewer A's in composition than in other courses, which raises a completely different set of questions. This semester I'm teaching two sections of composition and one literature course, so perhaps the spread will be different. Or not. And if it is (or isn't), what will that mean?
The final question is this: If A's indicate success, why do I see a high number of A's as some sort of failure?
Tuesday, February 20, 2007
We all fall down
So far this week, various people have wanted many different things from me:
1. My parking space.
2. Paczki.
3. Permission to drop a required freshman writing course because it conflicts with the student's major courses and besides, she doesn't really need writing in her real life.
4. A teaching schedule with no afternoon or Tuesday/Thursday classes.
5. Minutes of last week's Faculty Council meeting.
6. My umbrella.
7. My library card.
8. A clear explanation of just what Robert Frost meant by "Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening," including my opinion on whether the poem might really be talking about Santa Claus.
9. A job description for a sudden unexpected opening in the department.
10. A search committee for same.
11. Deadlines for submissions for departmental awards.
12. Grades on papers I collected only yesterday.
13. One hundred blank white index cards.
14. My department's opinion on 200 essays by prospective students.
15. A film canister full of ashes.
I've been pretty accommodating, but I've had to send a few people away empty-handed. No grades today, folks, and no free passes for freshman comp, but there are plenty of paczki left--or perhaps I can interest you in some perfectly lovely ashes?
For Lent, I think I'll give up listening.
1. My parking space.
2. Paczki.
3. Permission to drop a required freshman writing course because it conflicts with the student's major courses and besides, she doesn't really need writing in her real life.
4. A teaching schedule with no afternoon or Tuesday/Thursday classes.
5. Minutes of last week's Faculty Council meeting.
6. My umbrella.
7. My library card.
8. A clear explanation of just what Robert Frost meant by "Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening," including my opinion on whether the poem might really be talking about Santa Claus.
9. A job description for a sudden unexpected opening in the department.
10. A search committee for same.
11. Deadlines for submissions for departmental awards.
12. Grades on papers I collected only yesterday.
13. One hundred blank white index cards.
14. My department's opinion on 200 essays by prospective students.
15. A film canister full of ashes.
I've been pretty accommodating, but I've had to send a few people away empty-handed. No grades today, folks, and no free passes for freshman comp, but there are plenty of paczki left--or perhaps I can interest you in some perfectly lovely ashes?
For Lent, I think I'll give up listening.
Monday, February 19, 2007
Bloggers Without Borders
That's the title of a cartoon in a recent issue of the New Yorker. What is a Blogger Without Borders? Guy with a megaphone on a streetcorner.
I don't have a megaphone, but next week I'll be a Blogger Without Borders when I crawl out from the confines of this little space to give a paper at the AWP conference in Atlanta. That's the Association of Writers and Writing Programs, and no, I don't know why there's only one W in the acronym. Maybe the extra W escaped, or maybe it's being held for an exorbitant ransom by insidious anti-W forces, or maybe the W got off a the wrong metro stop and can't find Peachtree Street.
But if you are not an errant W and you know how to find Peachtree Street and you plan to be at the AWP conference next week, let's get together for coffee. Leave a comment if you're interested and then watch this space for the time and location of the first Bloggers Without Borders meeting. Megaphones optional.
I don't have a megaphone, but next week I'll be a Blogger Without Borders when I crawl out from the confines of this little space to give a paper at the AWP conference in Atlanta. That's the Association of Writers and Writing Programs, and no, I don't know why there's only one W in the acronym. Maybe the extra W escaped, or maybe it's being held for an exorbitant ransom by insidious anti-W forces, or maybe the W got off a the wrong metro stop and can't find Peachtree Street.
But if you are not an errant W and you know how to find Peachtree Street and you plan to be at the AWP conference next week, let's get together for coffee. Leave a comment if you're interested and then watch this space for the time and location of the first Bloggers Without Borders meeting. Megaphones optional.
Sunday, February 18, 2007
Albatross or anvil?
I see on the horizon a cloud no bigger than a man's hand, but I can't decide whether it looks more like a looming albatross or a falling anvil or a sign of soothing rain or whether it will drop with a gentle sigh or a screech or a splat. Will umbrellas be called for or something more sturdy? Will I laugh or cry or stand around looking stupid? No point in thinking about it, really. Sufficient unto the day are the evils thereof, and so on. Can't talk about it, shouldn't think about it, mustn't worry about it, really must move on whistling in the dark and hoping for rain, anvil or no anvil. The sun'll come out tomorrow, and that cloud? There's got to be a silver lining somewhere, and if someone will just distract the albatross for a moment while I shove this anvil out of the way, maybe we'll find it.
Friday, February 16, 2007
News flash! Prof denies paternity!
Shocking developments in the Anna Nicole Smith story: A local professor today issued a statement denying that he is the father of Anna Nicole Smith's baby.
"Rumors of our relationship are greatly exaggerated," he said, adding that he has "no comment" on allegations that he cavorted with Ms. Smith while his wife was on sabbatical. "I have no recollection of that," he insisted.
In an informal poll, 87 percent of faculty members questioned stated that it is "not impossible" that their colleague might be the father of Smith's baby. "He certainly speaks like a man with something to hide," said a Communications professor, while a prominent ethicist added, "Whatever he might or might not have done, I'm sure he had the best intentions."
The professor in question declined to confirm that he is willing to submit to a paternity test, saying, "You'll have to talk to my attorney about that." He did, however, pledge his undying support for the college. "I will not allow the media spotlight to distract me from my work here," he said, "and if, by some strange combination of events, I should suddenly come into a large sum of money, I promise to donate half of it toward the new library."
That's the news, fair and balanced as always.
"Rumors of our relationship are greatly exaggerated," he said, adding that he has "no comment" on allegations that he cavorted with Ms. Smith while his wife was on sabbatical. "I have no recollection of that," he insisted.
In an informal poll, 87 percent of faculty members questioned stated that it is "not impossible" that their colleague might be the father of Smith's baby. "He certainly speaks like a man with something to hide," said a Communications professor, while a prominent ethicist added, "Whatever he might or might not have done, I'm sure he had the best intentions."
The professor in question declined to confirm that he is willing to submit to a paternity test, saying, "You'll have to talk to my attorney about that." He did, however, pledge his undying support for the college. "I will not allow the media spotlight to distract me from my work here," he said, "and if, by some strange combination of events, I should suddenly come into a large sum of money, I promise to donate half of it toward the new library."
That's the news, fair and balanced as always.
Thursday, February 15, 2007
From LOL to COBASWAADFTFOTEL
Mark the date: today for the first time ever I found in a student paper the acronym "LOL," right smack in the middle of what was supposed to be an in-depth analytical essay. I confess that I did Laugh Out Loud, but it was not the Guffaw of Glee (GOG) but the Chortle of Bitter Anguish Suffused with Alarm and Despair for the Future of the English Language (COBASWAADFTFOTEL). That's a laugh no student wants to hear.
Wednesday, February 14, 2007
Staying alive
Take some snow followed closely by rain; freeze and then add more snow on top and whip it all up with some vicious wind and what do you get?
A Snow Day, that's what you get. I don't know what campus looks like but my road looks a thrill ride at Ice World, and let's not even talk about the driveway. I'm staying home today, but it's not exactly a day off. I've cancelled my only Wednesday class but I'm requiring the students to participate in an online discussion of the reading material so we don't fall too far behind. I'm using the same methods I developed for last semester's Pandemic Day (read about it here), and so far it seems to be working.
I'm also missing three meetings this afternoon, which is good news. Any three-meeting day is bound to be brutal, but three meetings occurring during my stupidest time of day--well, I'd rather be one of those hedgehogs in Alice's surreal croquet game. Being repeatedly hit by a croquet mallet can't possibly be any worse than being subjected to committee-conceived prose three times in one afternoon.
There will be consequences, of course. There are always consequences. We'll have to do a little catching up in the American Lit Survey class, and the three meetings will eventually be rescheduled, although perhaps not on the same day. But meanwhile, we're celebrating Valentine's Day by staying home--and staying alive.
A Snow Day, that's what you get. I don't know what campus looks like but my road looks a thrill ride at Ice World, and let's not even talk about the driveway. I'm staying home today, but it's not exactly a day off. I've cancelled my only Wednesday class but I'm requiring the students to participate in an online discussion of the reading material so we don't fall too far behind. I'm using the same methods I developed for last semester's Pandemic Day (read about it here), and so far it seems to be working.
I'm also missing three meetings this afternoon, which is good news. Any three-meeting day is bound to be brutal, but three meetings occurring during my stupidest time of day--well, I'd rather be one of those hedgehogs in Alice's surreal croquet game. Being repeatedly hit by a croquet mallet can't possibly be any worse than being subjected to committee-conceived prose three times in one afternoon.
There will be consequences, of course. There are always consequences. We'll have to do a little catching up in the American Lit Survey class, and the three meetings will eventually be rescheduled, although perhaps not on the same day. But meanwhile, we're celebrating Valentine's Day by staying home--and staying alive.
Tuesday, February 13, 2007
Taking a stand for concision
Half of my department stayed home today, either sick or stuck because of the weather. Several of my commuting students stayed home for similar reasons, and I don't blame them: while the roads here in town are not bad (which is saying a lot for the Land that Snowplows Forgot), the outlying areas are pretty treacherous. I live in one of those outlying areas and I did not enjoy the trip to town this morning.
I did, however, enjoy my 8:00 class, and I have been relishing reading drafts of their papers, even the one that referred to a particular feature of the baseball stadium as the "concision stand." I would like to send a few students to the concision stand: the one who begins 90 percent of his sentences with "There is" or "There are"; the one who loves to turn the simplest of syntax into a quivering mass of embedded "that" clauses; the one whose thesis statement features the phrase "it is to be concluded that." Go to the concision stand and trade in those wordy constructions for more concise expressions; toss out the convoluted institutional syntax and trade up to clear and possibly even elegant sentences. We need a concision stand in every classroom!
Right now, though, we don't even have a teacher in every classroom. But that's okay: the roads will not be treacherous forever, and even the flu will eventually move on--and maybe one day some of my students will discover the concision stand on their own.
I did, however, enjoy my 8:00 class, and I have been relishing reading drafts of their papers, even the one that referred to a particular feature of the baseball stadium as the "concision stand." I would like to send a few students to the concision stand: the one who begins 90 percent of his sentences with "There is" or "There are"; the one who loves to turn the simplest of syntax into a quivering mass of embedded "that" clauses; the one whose thesis statement features the phrase "it is to be concluded that." Go to the concision stand and trade in those wordy constructions for more concise expressions; toss out the convoluted institutional syntax and trade up to clear and possibly even elegant sentences. We need a concision stand in every classroom!
Right now, though, we don't even have a teacher in every classroom. But that's okay: the roads will not be treacherous forever, and even the flu will eventually move on--and maybe one day some of my students will discover the concision stand on their own.
Monday, February 12, 2007
Mastering Edgar Lee
The tables were turned in my American Lit Survey class this morning: generally I'm the one trying to persuade reluctant students to appreciate an author who makes them want to run screaming from the room, but today it was the other way around. The subject was Edgar Lee Masters. Now I admit that I have read and written on Masters and I have come to appreciate and perhaps even admire his accomplishment in Spoon River Anthology, but when it comes to actually reading the poems--well, I'd really rather not.
Many of my students, on the other hand, were enthusiastic about the six Masters poems in their anthology. "Help me to understand what you enjoy about these poems," I said, and they did: they like the individual voices that build a complex vision of the human condition; they like the little moral lessons liberally sprinkled among the poems; they like the scientific metaphors used to explain human behavior; and they really like the casual, almost raw language and free verse.
No one said anything about how heavy the poems feel, how lacking in awareness of the rhythms of the English language. There was some appreciation for the poet's liberal use of irony, but many students were eager to accept Masters's little sermonettes at face value, as if irony did not enter into the equation and the entire collection could be summed up by cliches about living life to the fullest. And while the students recognized the bleakness of Masters's vision, this did not prevent them from taking pleasure in the poems.
So I guess the problem is mine. I recently re-read all 300ish pages of Spoon River Anthology in preparation for a conference paper, and it felt like being force-fed tombstones: the poems are clunky and awkward and stink of the grave, and the language is turgid at times and generally uninspired. Here, for instance, is "Griffy the Cooper":
The cooper should know about tubs.
But I learned about life as well,
And you who loiter around these graves
Think you know life.
You think your eye sweeps about a wide horizon, perhaps,
In truth you are only looking around the interior of your tub.
You cannot lift yourself to its rim
And see the outer world of things,
And at the same time see yourself.
You are submerged in the tub of yourself--
Taboos and rules and appearances,
Are the staves of your tub.
Break them and dispel the witchcraft
Of thinking your tub is life!
And that you know life!
I suppose it's interesting to imagine that the local cooper could be Plato in disguise, but beyond that, this poem leaves me cold. It tells too much and tells it flatly, and it sounds like it ought to be read in that awful pretentious drone common to bad poetry readings, the voice suggesting that the poet is Very Very Serious while the rest of us are simply pathetic, unenlightened schmucks submerged in the tub of ourselves.
Maybe that's true. If so, it would explain why I don't enjoy reading Edgar Lee Masters. Appreciate, yes. Admire, yes. Enjoy? Never.
Many of my students, on the other hand, were enthusiastic about the six Masters poems in their anthology. "Help me to understand what you enjoy about these poems," I said, and they did: they like the individual voices that build a complex vision of the human condition; they like the little moral lessons liberally sprinkled among the poems; they like the scientific metaphors used to explain human behavior; and they really like the casual, almost raw language and free verse.
No one said anything about how heavy the poems feel, how lacking in awareness of the rhythms of the English language. There was some appreciation for the poet's liberal use of irony, but many students were eager to accept Masters's little sermonettes at face value, as if irony did not enter into the equation and the entire collection could be summed up by cliches about living life to the fullest. And while the students recognized the bleakness of Masters's vision, this did not prevent them from taking pleasure in the poems.
So I guess the problem is mine. I recently re-read all 300ish pages of Spoon River Anthology in preparation for a conference paper, and it felt like being force-fed tombstones: the poems are clunky and awkward and stink of the grave, and the language is turgid at times and generally uninspired. Here, for instance, is "Griffy the Cooper":
The cooper should know about tubs.
But I learned about life as well,
And you who loiter around these graves
Think you know life.
You think your eye sweeps about a wide horizon, perhaps,
In truth you are only looking around the interior of your tub.
You cannot lift yourself to its rim
And see the outer world of things,
And at the same time see yourself.
You are submerged in the tub of yourself--
Taboos and rules and appearances,
Are the staves of your tub.
Break them and dispel the witchcraft
Of thinking your tub is life!
And that you know life!
I suppose it's interesting to imagine that the local cooper could be Plato in disguise, but beyond that, this poem leaves me cold. It tells too much and tells it flatly, and it sounds like it ought to be read in that awful pretentious drone common to bad poetry readings, the voice suggesting that the poet is Very Very Serious while the rest of us are simply pathetic, unenlightened schmucks submerged in the tub of ourselves.
Maybe that's true. If so, it would explain why I don't enjoy reading Edgar Lee Masters. Appreciate, yes. Admire, yes. Enjoy? Never.
Friday, February 09, 2007
Feeding time, all the time
The house is quiet with the men out of town, which makes it much easier to hear the sounds I'm accustomed to ignoring, from the wail of the woodburner to the call of the cat. The cat wonders where the young man is. "He's in Texas looking at a college," I tell her, but she just looks at me with "Feed me" in her eyes. I point out that I just fed her a little while ago and there's plenty of food in her dish. Somehow, this fails to satisfy.
Satisfying the woodburner is another problem entirely. I can count on the cat to come crawling around my ankles when she's hungry, but the woodburner has selected a more nefarious method: it has wheedled its way into my subconscious mind, where it patiently waits until I am sound asleep and then jerks me to alertness with an urgent demand that I feed the fire. "But I already fed you," I tell the woodburner. "Now go away and let me sleep." So it goes off and sulks in my subconscious again until I'm just edging into blissful sleep and then there it is again, that panicky voice screaming "Feed the fire!"
It doesn't matter how many times I tell the woodburner "I just fed you," because its listening skills are no better than the cat's. In fact, the cat is so adept at ignoring all communiques from Planet Human that I ought to take advantage of that skill. The next time the fully-loaded woodburner comes screaming to me for more wood, I'll try a different approach. "Go tell it to the cat," I'll say. "I'm sure she'll listen."
Satisfying the woodburner is another problem entirely. I can count on the cat to come crawling around my ankles when she's hungry, but the woodburner has selected a more nefarious method: it has wheedled its way into my subconscious mind, where it patiently waits until I am sound asleep and then jerks me to alertness with an urgent demand that I feed the fire. "But I already fed you," I tell the woodburner. "Now go away and let me sleep." So it goes off and sulks in my subconscious again until I'm just edging into blissful sleep and then there it is again, that panicky voice screaming "Feed the fire!"
It doesn't matter how many times I tell the woodburner "I just fed you," because its listening skills are no better than the cat's. In fact, the cat is so adept at ignoring all communiques from Planet Human that I ought to take advantage of that skill. The next time the fully-loaded woodburner comes screaming to me for more wood, I'll try a different approach. "Go tell it to the cat," I'll say. "I'm sure she'll listen."
Thursday, February 08, 2007
An incomplete education
Over at rateyourstudents this week scholars have been griping about research and publication, and it's just depressing. Here is a typical comment:
Academic publishing has long been a joke. We all can pretend that scholarship and research may fire our own teaching, but really it's just masturbatory indulgence. I don't write for any other reason than to thicken my tenure portfolio. I rarely write about things that interest me; I never write about anything that would mean a bit to my sophomore seminar students.
This is the saddest thing I've read all week. Here we have a person who has apparently put a lot of time, effort, and money into getting academic credentials without ever discovering how to make meaningful connections among his scholarship, his pedagogy, and his passions. What is the point of such a woefully incomplete education? The world is not exactly crying out for more passionless writing and teaching. Who is at fault here? And what is the cure?
Academic publishing has long been a joke. We all can pretend that scholarship and research may fire our own teaching, but really it's just masturbatory indulgence. I don't write for any other reason than to thicken my tenure portfolio. I rarely write about things that interest me; I never write about anything that would mean a bit to my sophomore seminar students.
This is the saddest thing I've read all week. Here we have a person who has apparently put a lot of time, effort, and money into getting academic credentials without ever discovering how to make meaningful connections among his scholarship, his pedagogy, and his passions. What is the point of such a woefully incomplete education? The world is not exactly crying out for more passionless writing and teaching. Who is at fault here? And what is the cure?
Wednesday, February 07, 2007
Snow day
The view outside my window this morning is spectacular: everything is covered with snow, even the branches of tall trees. The sun is just coming up, making the frosted landscape sparkle and glow. I saw a truck drive by on the road a few minutes ago, but the road itself is still invisible.
Every public school in the area is closed today and every community college, but my institution remains open on the theory that the students are there anyway so we may as well teach 'em something. After a while we'll set out to try to retrieve my car, but my class starts at 11 today so I'll give the snowplows some time to do their work first. I'll be sure to take a change of clothes with me today so I can stay in town tonight if I have to, provided that I get to town--and if I don't, I'm sure my students wouldn't object to an unexpected day off.
Every public school in the area is closed today and every community college, but my institution remains open on the theory that the students are there anyway so we may as well teach 'em something. After a while we'll set out to try to retrieve my car, but my class starts at 11 today so I'll give the snowplows some time to do their work first. I'll be sure to take a change of clothes with me today so I can stay in town tonight if I have to, provided that I get to town--and if I don't, I'm sure my students wouldn't object to an unexpected day off.
Tuesday, February 06, 2007
Adventures in Commuting
This evening's Adventure in Commuting began with a quick visit to the grocery store, which was crowded with people stocking up on the staples they need to survive the snowstorm that began this afternoon and threatens to continue most of the night. It's always interesting to see what people think they'll need to get them through a weather disaster: the store's stocks of milk, eggs, and toilet paper were pretty well depleted, and many shoppers were pushing around carts full of canned goods. The guy in front of me at the checkout line had simpler needs: a case of beer and a frozen loaf of garlic bread. Hope he's planning to stay in for a while.
I made it about a third of the way home before being defeated by a hill. My van wasn't willing to go up the hill, and I wasn't interested in finding out what would happen if it tried to negotiate the S-curve on the downhill side. Rear-wheel drive is not the smart choice in this kind of weather; besides, I get a little nervous when I can't even see where the road is. So I abandoned my van at a convenience store and called home for reinforcements. The fearless husband, who grew up outside Cleveland and believes he can drive through anything, came and rescued me, but I notice that he took the big hill in second gear all the way and never got above 7 mph. My Adventure in Commuting ended with a quick dash up the driveway and a pause to appreciate the beauty of the snow. Let it fall. I'm staying home.
I made it about a third of the way home before being defeated by a hill. My van wasn't willing to go up the hill, and I wasn't interested in finding out what would happen if it tried to negotiate the S-curve on the downhill side. Rear-wheel drive is not the smart choice in this kind of weather; besides, I get a little nervous when I can't even see where the road is. So I abandoned my van at a convenience store and called home for reinforcements. The fearless husband, who grew up outside Cleveland and believes he can drive through anything, came and rescued me, but I notice that he took the big hill in second gear all the way and never got above 7 mph. My Adventure in Commuting ended with a quick dash up the driveway and a pause to appreciate the beauty of the snow. Let it fall. I'm staying home.
The Comma Fairy is very unhappy!
The eyeballs are suffering from overload after attending to a pile of freshman drafts and another pile of literature papers asking me to think about "various different literary works" that display the influence of "various different isms," but here's the question that keeps running through my mind: where did all the punctuation go? I've long accepted the fact that many students don't know the difference between a colon and a semicolon or a hyphen and a dash, but now even the commas are disappearing. I see "however" plunked down in the middle of a sentence without its full complement of commas, and I see "for example" or "obviously" or "in addition" at the beginning of a sentence with no happy little comma following.
I have seen entire papers lacking any trace of commas, and I have seen several other papers that insert commas only where they are least welcome: separating a verb from its subject. I don't know how many times today I have read sentences starting like this: "The Yellow Wallpaper," is a story about....
What is that comma doing there? And why am I seeing so many examples of this annoyingly intrusive comma when other places are just crying out for commas but remain bereft? Today the Comma Fairy sits alone in her lair, where she sifts stacks of neglected commas while plaintively singing, "Where have all the commas gone?" Someday, though, she'll get tired of singing and step out to take vengeance on those who have so cruelly rejected her--or else she'll slowly wander off into the sunset arm-in-arm with the Hyphen Helper, the Semicolon Sylph, and the High and Exalted Annunciator of Ampersands. And I, for one, will be sorry to see them go.
I have seen entire papers lacking any trace of commas, and I have seen several other papers that insert commas only where they are least welcome: separating a verb from its subject. I don't know how many times today I have read sentences starting like this: "The Yellow Wallpaper," is a story about....
What is that comma doing there? And why am I seeing so many examples of this annoyingly intrusive comma when other places are just crying out for commas but remain bereft? Today the Comma Fairy sits alone in her lair, where she sifts stacks of neglected commas while plaintively singing, "Where have all the commas gone?" Someday, though, she'll get tired of singing and step out to take vengeance on those who have so cruelly rejected her--or else she'll slowly wander off into the sunset arm-in-arm with the Hyphen Helper, the Semicolon Sylph, and the High and Exalted Annunciator of Ampersands. And I, for one, will be sorry to see them go.
Monday, February 05, 2007
Another turnip trauma
Now that the trauma is fading into memory and the household has been purged of all trace of the offending substance, I am at liberty to describe what may well have been the most wretched meal I have ever encountered. The only meal in memory that even comes close was the incident with the dog-hairs in the frosting, and that occurred in another time and another place--and it was not perpetrated by someone with whom I expect to spend the rest of my life. When a neighbor serves you a birthday cake studded with dog hairs, you can at least take comfort in mentally inventing excuses to avoid eating there again. This option is unavailable when the cook is the love of your life.
The current culinary trauma occurred last Thursday, when my wonderful helpful husband called me at the office with exciting news: "Don't worry about supper," he said. "I put some bratwurst and turnips in the crockpot."
I was not, as you would imagine, overcome with glee at his words, but I knew he was just trying to be supportive. Still, I steeled myself for the ordeal ahead by stopping at the grocery store on the way home and stocking up on ice cream, just in case we might need a little distraction after the main dish.
And what a dish it was. My husband makes bread to die for and grilled meats to make Bobby Flay salivate, but crockpot cooking is not his forte. While turnips and bratwurst made up the base of the stew, he had also added little dabs of this and that from the fridge: pepperoni, frozen summer squash, ground pork, mashed potatoes, green beans, and I was afraid to ask what else. These duelling ingredients congealed into a gloppy mass with a consistency and texture not unlike that of vomit, only with bigger chunks.
And the flavor! Let us pass silently over the folly of mixing the bland with the ridiculous. My son and I looked at each other over the crockpot and struggled to find words to express a complex message: "We appreciate the effort, but please don't ever do it again!" After dutifully finishing a petite portion, I put down my fork and said brightly, "I hope you like this, honey, because I suspect you'll be eating a lot of it in the next few days!"
And he did. The young man and I have been studiously ignoring the leftover Turnip and Bratwurst Surprise lingering loathesomely in the refrigerator, but the husband doesn't believe in wasting food so he has been making steady progress on the diminishing disaster. He doesn't complain, and neither do I. It was edible, after all, and it wasn't decorated with dog hairs.
And best of all, it's gone.
The current culinary trauma occurred last Thursday, when my wonderful helpful husband called me at the office with exciting news: "Don't worry about supper," he said. "I put some bratwurst and turnips in the crockpot."
I was not, as you would imagine, overcome with glee at his words, but I knew he was just trying to be supportive. Still, I steeled myself for the ordeal ahead by stopping at the grocery store on the way home and stocking up on ice cream, just in case we might need a little distraction after the main dish.
And what a dish it was. My husband makes bread to die for and grilled meats to make Bobby Flay salivate, but crockpot cooking is not his forte. While turnips and bratwurst made up the base of the stew, he had also added little dabs of this and that from the fridge: pepperoni, frozen summer squash, ground pork, mashed potatoes, green beans, and I was afraid to ask what else. These duelling ingredients congealed into a gloppy mass with a consistency and texture not unlike that of vomit, only with bigger chunks.
And the flavor! Let us pass silently over the folly of mixing the bland with the ridiculous. My son and I looked at each other over the crockpot and struggled to find words to express a complex message: "We appreciate the effort, but please don't ever do it again!" After dutifully finishing a petite portion, I put down my fork and said brightly, "I hope you like this, honey, because I suspect you'll be eating a lot of it in the next few days!"
And he did. The young man and I have been studiously ignoring the leftover Turnip and Bratwurst Surprise lingering loathesomely in the refrigerator, but the husband doesn't believe in wasting food so he has been making steady progress on the diminishing disaster. He doesn't complain, and neither do I. It was edible, after all, and it wasn't decorated with dog hairs.
And best of all, it's gone.
Saturday, February 03, 2007
Unnatural Voices
Just to show that I'm capable of saying something positive about a new work of literary criticism, let me share how much I'm enjoying Unnatural Voices: Extreme Narration in Modern and Contemporary Fiction by Brian Richardson. I'm just two chapters in and I have already written my name in the book, which means it's a keeper. The prose is clear, the reasoning sophisticated, and the scope admirable--and best of all, he approaches the topic with a refreshing originality and depth of insight, making me want to revisit the literature and rethink my assumptions. I envision assigning part or all of the book in my upper-level novel class, which focuses on twentieth-century experiments in narration; even students who resist thinking about formal elements of narration will find Richardson's argument and examples engaging. Besides that, the cover illustration is neat. Gold stars all around.
Friday, February 02, 2007
Buy the book!
Roughly 90 pages into a new and much-anticipated work of literary criticism, I finally gave up. The wonder is that I made it that far. The prose is leaden, the analysis uninspired, and the supporting points so obvious they would not be out of place in an undergraduate research paper. This book, though, was written by a distinguished senior scholar and published by a reputable university press; it has been very well reviewed and I had been looking forward to reading it for some time. I slogged through the first insipid half of the book hoping for more meat later on, but then I encountered this passage:
"Morrison's exploration of desire in Jazz reaches its climax at the midpoint of the story when spring arrives in Harlem. This timing strikes the reader as natural and spontaneous because spring in the Northern Hemisphere brings renewal of life on Earth. For young and old Harlemites, spring--perhaps a season of emotion just as autumn is a season of intellect--stimulates one's latent desire."
Then, just in case thick-headed readers have somehow failed to absord the spring = renewal = desire equation, the author adds a paragraph summarizing other literary works that have made the same connection. T.S. Eliot, for instance, in case you hadn't heard, calls April "the cruellest month" but also emphasizes spring's fecundity, while Henry James sends Chad Newsome and Mme de Vionnet out on a boat in--you guessed it--spring!
What we have here is a distinguished scholar telling us that spring is the time when a young man's fancy turns to love, and a young woman's too. Oddly enough, I didn't need to read an expensive hardback book to discover that insight.
But maybe you do. If so, I'd be happy to sell you my copy.
"Morrison's exploration of desire in Jazz reaches its climax at the midpoint of the story when spring arrives in Harlem. This timing strikes the reader as natural and spontaneous because spring in the Northern Hemisphere brings renewal of life on Earth. For young and old Harlemites, spring--perhaps a season of emotion just as autumn is a season of intellect--stimulates one's latent desire."
Then, just in case thick-headed readers have somehow failed to absord the spring = renewal = desire equation, the author adds a paragraph summarizing other literary works that have made the same connection. T.S. Eliot, for instance, in case you hadn't heard, calls April "the cruellest month" but also emphasizes spring's fecundity, while Henry James sends Chad Newsome and Mme de Vionnet out on a boat in--you guessed it--spring!
What we have here is a distinguished scholar telling us that spring is the time when a young man's fancy turns to love, and a young woman's too. Oddly enough, I didn't need to read an expensive hardback book to discover that insight.
But maybe you do. If so, I'd be happy to sell you my copy.
Give a hoot
Yesterday a sign in front of a local business proclaimed the following message: "balls hooting clinic."
1. What kind of business?
2. What does it mean?
1. What kind of business?
2. What does it mean?
Thursday, February 01, 2007
Why I love winter
1. Pollen and leaf mold and other allergens get locked into the frozen ground and covered by snow so I can breathe freely for a change.
2. Classroom temperatures remain a little chilly, but I don't resent a cold classroom in January as much as I resent a bitterly cold classroom in July, when the building is both cold and damp.
3. My woods look like a picture postcard, all the dead brown stuff covered with a light white frosting of snow.
4. Juncos come back with the snow to entertain me.
5. No one begs me to go out for a walk when it's this cold.
6. There's nothing bluer than a clear blue winter sky.
7. Wool socks make me warm all over.
8. We heat our house with wood, which means our winter electric bills are half the size of our summer bills.
9. All my best teaching clothes are wool.
10. Cold weather is good for the constitution, making us feel as if we've triumphed over some challenge of mythic proportions. And we have.
2. Classroom temperatures remain a little chilly, but I don't resent a cold classroom in January as much as I resent a bitterly cold classroom in July, when the building is both cold and damp.
3. My woods look like a picture postcard, all the dead brown stuff covered with a light white frosting of snow.
4. Juncos come back with the snow to entertain me.
5. No one begs me to go out for a walk when it's this cold.
6. There's nothing bluer than a clear blue winter sky.
7. Wool socks make me warm all over.
8. We heat our house with wood, which means our winter electric bills are half the size of our summer bills.
9. All my best teaching clothes are wool.
10. Cold weather is good for the constitution, making us feel as if we've triumphed over some challenge of mythic proportions. And we have.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


